he stated as follows in Re Parliamentary Election for Fermanagh:
“The final issue is that contained in section 23(3)(a) of the 1983
Act, whether the election was so conducted as to be substantially
in accordance with the law as to elections. In our view this phrase
refers to the election as a whole, not to the proceedings at the
particular polling station. Statements of the law suggest that for
the breach of election law to be regarded as substantial there has
to be something which would make one have serious doubt
whether the election was a proper manifestation of the wishes of
the electorate in choosing their member.”
The judgment in the High Court
[131]
Having found that Rule 1(7) was breached by the late opening of the polls, the
judge stated as follows, as it related to the question whether there was substantial
compliance:72
“[229] … taking the totality of the circumstances into account including the
fact that a significant percentage of the electorate voted, the Court must
examine whether there was a real ballot. Utilizing the well-known
examples referred to in Morgan v Simpson, the Court is not of the view
that the election was a sham or a travesty, there is no evidence that
persons who voted were not lawfully entitled to do so.
[230] Further, it is worth indicating that the election was conducted in
substantial accordance with the election law. The Court is guided by the
reasoning provided by Stephenson LJ in Morgan v Simpson, namely:
‘For an election to be conducted substantially in accordance with the
law there must be a real election by ballot and no such departure
from the procedure laid down by parliament as to make the ordinary
man condemn the election as a sham or travesty of an election.
Instances of such a substantial departure would be allowing voters to
vote for a person who was not in fact a candidate or refusing to
accept a qualified candidate on some legal ground or disenfranchise
a substantial portion of qualified voters’.”
[132]
As far as the burden of proof is concerned, she stated73 that there is no onus on
the respondent to prove, in the event of a breach (which is the petitioner’s burden),
that the election was nevertheless conducted so as to be substantially in
72
73
At paragraphs 229 and 230 of the judgment.
At paragraph 231 of the judgment.
56
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents