Court on which it can be determined that in spite of the late opening of the polling stations the entire constituency polled out before the close of poll, the Court acting sensibly would not hold that there was not substantial compliance. See Borough of Drogbeda supra, in which it was clear that only a small number was affected by the breach and it could be positively shown that this did not affect the result. [236] It is the Court’s considered view, that the petition at bar, is to be compared with the decision in the Hackney case in which 2 out of 19 polling stations did not open, (disenfranchising some 4,900 out of 41,000 voters) and 3 other polling stations (with a possible total of about 3,900) were only open for part of the day. A large number of voters were affected or it might reasonably be supposed that they were prevented from voting. Grove J found that the election was not conducted substantially in accordance with the law as to election. The election was therefore declared invalid. [237] It is therefore imperative for the Court to examine in totality, the circumstances in which the polling occurred in order to determine whether the election was conducted substantially in accordance with the election law. Each petition will turn on its own facts and the Court is required to take an objective and just approach in its determination of this aspect of the matter. With that principle in mind, the Court is of the view that given that only a few hours of voting were lost, coupled with the fact that a very significant percentage of electorate in the constituency of St . George voted, there is no reason for the Court not to conclude that there was substantial compliance. [238] … the Court should seek to determine what was achieved despite the hours that were lost. The Court is required to adopt a commonsense approach in its determination of whether in view of the totality of the circumstances it could be said that there was substantial compliance with the law. See Redhead J in Halstead v Simon supra. [239]The Court has also given much consideration to Halstead v Simon supra on which all of the parties have relied on in support of their respective positions. Taking into account the totality of the circumstances, the Court is not of the view that there was substantial non-compliance with the election law.” [135] With respect to the St. John’s Rural North constituency, having repeated that the petitioner had clearly lead incontrovertible evidence upon which she found that voters were denied their right to vote due to the late opening of the polls, the learned trial judge stated as follows:80 “[395] The Court however, has no evidence on which it can conclude as to 80 At paragraphs 395 and 396. 58

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents