the exact number of persons who were disenfranchised by the late
opening of the poll, or the number of persons who could have voted in the
constituency of St. John’s Rural North but did not do so because of the
late opening. The evidence does, however, support the conclusion that
there was a substantial percentage of the electorate that exercised its
franchise.
[396] Indeed the Court accepts that despite the late opening, some 80.4%
of the electorate voted. This is indeed a very high percentage. Relatedly,
the Court has no doubt that this election could not be considered to be a
sham or a travesty. Indeed, it was a real election by ballot and there was
substantial compliance with the law in relation to Election. In a word, once
again the Court is of the view that there was nevertheless substantial
compliance with the Election Law.”
[136]
The judge noted,81 with respect to the St. John Rural West constituency, that
polling commenced at least 1 hour and 30 minutes late at the stations at Miss G,
St. Ann’s Church, Multipurpose Centre, and at the Nazarene Church. Polling
commenced 4 hours late at Five Islands. At Greenbay, which is the largest of the
polling stations, it opened in excess of 6 hours late. The judge restated her finding
that several persons left the polling station at Greenbay and at the Five Islands
polling station due to the late opening of the poll, and that while some of these
persons returned and were able to cast their votes others did not. Moreover, she
concluded, from the evidence, that an indeterminate number of persons were
unable to cast their votes due to the late opening of the polls. She stated,82 that
notwithstanding the lost voting hours, there was clear evidence that 80.48% of the
registered voters voted in the constituency. She found that by any assessment this
was a very significant turn out. She said that she found very persuasive the
statement by Redhead J in Halstead v Simon that, on that evidence, the election
could not be condemned as a sham or travesty in such circumstances, particularly
as the percentage turnout was greater than in some of the other constituencies
notwithstanding the late opening of the polls.
81
82
At paragraph 272 of the judgment.
At paragraph 273 of the judgment.
59
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents