[144]
Counsel suggested that we should instead be guided by the decision in the
Borough of Drogbeda case.94 In this case it was proved that due to some
unforeseen accident the 7 polling stations were not opened at the statutory hour of
8am and no votes were received until 8:45am. Counsel said that it was clear that
the late opening had no effect upon the result of the election and that not a single
voter was in consequence prevented from voting. In fact, stated counsel, the
whole constituency was almost entirely polled out before the poll was closed.
Counsel asked this court to note the following statement in that case by Barry J:95
“… to hold an election void under such circumstances as the
present would be to put it in the power of any careless or corrupt
presiding officer in any one polling station to nullify the solemn act
of the largest constituency in the Kingdom.”
Submissions on behalf of the respondents
[145]
Mr. Guthrie and Mr. Astaphan, counsel for the respondents, stated that the trial
judge correctly identified96 the 2 issues that arise on section 32(4) of the
Representation of the People Act as follows:
(i) was the election conducted so badly that it was not substantially in
accordance with the law as to elections, so that it was invalid, whether the
result was affected or not?
(ii) even if the election was conducted so as to be substantially in accordance
with the law as to elections, does it appear that the breaches of the law did not
affect the result?
[146]
On the issue of substantial compliance, counsel submitted that ‘substantially’ as it
appears in section 32(4) is a question of degree. From this perspective, counsel
contended that whether there was substantial compliance may not be the same in
the constituency of St John’s Rural North, where there was no late voting, as in St
John’s Rural West, where the late opening of the polls was the most delayed, and
(1874) 2 OM & H 201.
At page 203 of the Report.
96 Especially at paragraphs 201 – 202 of the judgment.
94
95
63
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents