late voting extended over a long period. Counsel suggested the court’s decision
should take into account that the opportunity to vote is crucial to any election, and
the Election Rules are intended to ensure that it exists. Counsel submitted,
correctly, in my view, that if the relevant Rule is breached so that the opportunity to
vote is substantially compromised, the election cannot properly be said to have
been conducted substantially in accordance with the law as to elections.
[147]
With regard to the passage in the judgment of Stephenson LJ in Morgan v
Simpson which the trial judge mentioned97 counsel asked us to note that the
judge omitted the words “but not such an irregularity as was committed in this case
…” that follow where her quotation ended. Counsel submitted, correctly, in my
view, that those omitted words show that the passage was obiter, so that
Stephenson LJ was not limiting the circumstances in which the facts might show
that an election was not conducted substantially in accordance with the law. This,
in my view, reflects that the basic principle in determining whether there was
substantial compliance must be decided with reference to the facts and the
circumstances in each case. It appears to me that the learned trial judge intended
to capture the basic principles rather than to apply Morgan v Simpson.
[148]
Mr. Astaphan noted that the trial judge found on the facts of the present case that
there was a real election by ballot; that a substantial portion of the electorate
voted, and that the election could not be described as a sham or travesty. He
insisted that the same things can be said of Hackney, which was expressly
approved by Morgan v Simpson.98 It is clear that the required exercise is not to
be guided by application, comparison or distinguishing of cases. While decided
cases may afford some guidance, the decision whether there was substantial
compliance in the conduct of an election is to be decided on the circumstances in
each case.
97
98
At paragraph 230 of the judgment.
[1974] 3 All E.R. 722, at page 728.
64
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents