[149]
Counsel for the respondents contended that on this issue, the trial judge left out of
consideration, with regard to the constituencies of St George and St John’s Rural
West, the fact of late voting, which, as the respondents have submitted, was also
in breach of electoral law. In the circumstances, said counsel, on the evidence in
the present cases, it cannot properly be said that the elections were conducted
substantially in accordance with electoral law where the polling stations were
closed for large parts of the allotted time, and where voting was permitted for
considerable periods outside the allotted time. These breaches, submitted
counsel, went to the heart of the democratic process. I have concluded, however,
that the trial judge correctly decided that the circumstances in which late voting
occurred did not occasion a breach of electoral law.
[150]
Finally, learned counsel drew attention to what he said was a misleading and
incorrect aspect of the appellants’ submissions in relation to Halstead. In their
submissions, counsel for the appellants contended that Redhead J stated99 that
“the election was not conducted in a way as to make the ordinary man deem it as
a sham or travesty” and that “there is no doubt that there was a real election by
ballot.” Counsel noted that the appellants also stated that Redhead J concluded
that the election was conducted substantially in accordance with electoral law,100
but that they added a footnote stating that “As will be shown later, Redhead J then
proceeded quite inexplicably to rule that the election was not conducted in
substantial compliance with the law as to elections.” Thereby, said Mr. Astaphan,
the appellants attempted to rely on and to distinguish Halstead, which is an
authority against them. Mr. Astaphan insisted that counsel for the appellants
misunderstood Redhead J’s judgment. He pointed out that Redhead J did not
conclude “that the election was conducted substantially in accordance with the law
as to elections”. Rather, insisted Mr. Astaphan, he found that the election was not
conducted in such a way as to make the ordinary man condemn it as a sham or
travesty; that there was a real election by ballot; that the secrecy of the ballot was
99
See page 229.
See at page 233.
100
65
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents