not violated in any way; and that there was not a disenfranchising of a substantial
portion of the electorate. Mr. Astaphan insisted that none of these matters
answered the question posed by the law, which Redhead J proceeded to ask in
this way: “Was the election so conducted as to be substantially in accordance with
the law as to elections?” He answered the question in the negative, said counsel,
so that there is nothing “inexplicable” about this approach: it is the correct
application of the law.
Decision on the judge’s finding on substantial compliance
[151]
I agree that the approach by Redhead J to this question was the correct approach
in considering this issue. The focus is on ‘substantial compliance’ with the law in
the conduct of the election. The concern is not only with the results but more so
on actual compliance with electoral law. The quintessential question that the court
must ask, in effect, is what matters went wrong with the conduct of the elections
that render the conduct inconsistent with the procedures stipulated by law. The
court must consider whether a petitioner has proved that things were done which
electoral law proscribes. The court must then, consider all of the surrounding
circumstances and determine whether the degree of non-compliance was
‘substantial’. That is, that the degree of non-compliance was such that the election
may be invalidated on the ground that its conduct was not in substantial
compliance with elections law.
[152]
In effect, the judge took into account in each case the actual time when voting
commenced and the result achieved despite the late start in voting in the 3
contested constituencies. She was impressed by the fact that the voter turnout
was quite high in each constituency (all around 80%).101 She was of the view that
“in seeking to ascertain whether there was substantial compliance with the law or
the rule relating to the opening hours, the Court should seek to determine what
101
See generally paragraphs 233-240, 273-275 and 392-396.
66
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents