was achieved in spite of the hours that were lost.”102 She held that “if there is
cogent evidence before the court on which it can be determined that in spite of the
late opening of the polling stations the entire constituency polled out before the
close of the poll, the Court acting sensibly would not hold that there was not
substantial compliance.”103
[153]
In the present case the learned judge found, correctly, in my view, that the late
opening of the polls in the 3 contested constituencies breached Rule 1(7) of the
Election Rules. However, she found that this breach did not in and of itself mean
that there was not substantial compliance with the law as to elections. In so doing,
she examined the circumstances that were relevant to an assessment of this issue
from the perspective of late opening of the polls as reflected in the paragraphs of
her judgment which are reproduced above. She further found that there was late
voting but concluded that this did not occasion a breach of electoral law. In my
view, she was correct in her decision that there was substantial compliance with
electoral law notwithstanding the breach of Rule 1(7) occasioned by the late
opening of the polls in the 3 contested constituencies. I would therefore dismiss
those grounds of the counter-appeal which challenge the judge’s decision on this
issue.
Was there substantial compliance in the totality of the circumstances?
[154]
Mr. Guthrie and Mr. Astaphan insisted that on the evidence in the present case, it
cannot properly be said that the elections were conducted substantially in
accordance with electoral law where polling stations are closed for large parts of
the allotted time, and where in 2 of the contested constituencies voting continued
for considerable periods after the statutory closing time. The respondents each
complain in their counter-notices that late voting and the late opening of polling
stations, separately and cumulatively meant that the election was not conducted
102
103
Paragraph 238.
Paragraph 235.
67
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents