too were unable to vote due to the breach of the election laws occasioned
by the late opening.
[242] Having given careful scrutiny to all the cogent evidence adduced in
this petition, the Court is sure that an indeterminate number of persons
were prevented from voting during the hours that were lost. It bears
repeating that 926 of the electorate did not vote. The margin of victory
between the winning Respondent and the Petitioner was 502 votes. The
Court has already found as a fact that several persons who attempted to
vote and were in the line at 6:00 a.m. left the queue when the polls did not
open on time. Included in these persons were Ms. Denise Marshal, Ms.
Shensaba Henry and Mr. Alvor Brown, Mr. Goldburn Samuel. In addition,
several unnamed persons were similarly affected. The Court accepts that
79% of the electorate of St. George voted in 2009 as compared to 92.25%
in 2004 General Elections. Myriad factors could have accounted for this
fall in the turnout. This Court …however is not about to speculate as to
the reason for this. It bears stating that a Court of law can hardly feel
comfortable in making the sort of assumptions that it was invited to make
by the First Respondent. In the absence of any evidence to substantiate
the various contentions that different percentages of the electorate voted
at various times during the election, it is unclear how the Court can accept
the bold assertion one way or the other based on mere percentages. This
is to be contrasted with the clear and definitive evidence in the Islington
case.
[243] On the cogent evidence presented, the Court is sure that an
indeterminate number of persons were unable to vote due to the late
opening of the poll. This has a significant bearing on the Court’s
resolution of this aspect of the petition. In seeking to determine whether
the breach of the law affected the result the test as stated in Morgan v
Simpson arises for consideration. It is clear that this test is applicable
where the effect of the breach is known. However, when the effect of the
breach is not known, the applicable test is that in Edgell v Glover, which
was later approved in Considine v Didrichsen supra, whether it does not
appear that the result was not affected.
[244] I can do no more than adopt those helpful principles. This was also
the approach taken by Redhead J in Halstead when he stated at page 60
as follows:
“I find it difficult to say definitely that the result was affected or
would not have been affected by the irregularity.”
The Learned Judge therefore declared that the election was invalid.
This is to be contrasted with Evo v Supra [1986] LRC 18, in which
the Petitioner had complained that 154 persons voted who were not
lawfully entitled to vote. The Petitioner argued that the election was
void because their votes were illegal. It was held that there was
substantial compliance with the law and that even if the 154 votes
were given to the Petitioners, the result would not have been
affected.
71
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents