[163]
She reasoned as follows in the Simon/Spencer case:107
“[276] The Court must now go on to examine whether the breach of the
election law affected the result. In ascertaining the position in regard to
this issue, the Court pays cognizance to the uncontroverted evidence that
several persons who attempted to vote at 6 am were unable to do so.
Included in this category of persons are Mr. Winston Joseph and Mr.
Francias Matthias. Also the Court has reviewed the entire evidence and
concludes that an indeterminate number of persons were unable to vote.
Also, the Court is fortified in this view, having examined the evidence that
was provided by the witnesses who testified on behalf of the First
Respondent. They corroborated the Petitioner’s witnesses' evidence on
this issue.
[277] It may well be that the Court is unable to say that the breach
affected the result. The Court is of the view that the Morgan v Simpson
principles as applied in Considine v Didrichsen supra have direct
relevance to this petition. This percentage of persons who did not vote is
a matter for the Court to take into account in determining whether the
breach affected the result. The Court is not about to speculate as to the
reasons why nearly 20% of the electorate did not vote.
[278] The Court reiterates that what is important to determine is whether
the Court can say that the breach of the election did not affect the result.
[279] In the present petition where there is a margin of victory of 502
coupled with the fact that approximately 20% did not vote that represents
a significant number in excess of the margin of victory between the two
parties, and the fact that an indeterminate number of the electorate was
unable to vote in the election, due to late opening of the poll, the Court
cannot say that the breach of the election law did not affect the result.
The Court is unable to conclude, in view of the preponderance of the
evidence, that the breach of the election law did not affect the result.
[280] As a consequence, utilizing the principles propounded in Morgan v
Simpson as applied in Considine v Didrichsen and Edgell v Glover,
the Court has no alternative other than to declare the election void.
Accordingly, the Court declares that Mr. Baldwin Spencer was not duly
elected.”
The appeals on this issue
[164]
The appellants contend, in their notices of appeal, that the trial judge erred when
she invalidated their elections on the ground that she could not say that late
opening of the polls did not affect the result. They argue, in effect, that she
107
At paragraphs 276-280 of the judgment.
73
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents