cognisance of the question that the election was not so conducted as
to be substantially in accordance with the law as to elections or that
the act or omission did affect the result."
I think that the section should be transformed so as to read positively in
the way I have stated. I have come to this conclusion from the history of
the law as to elections and the cases under the statutes to which I now
turn, underlining the important points.”
Lord Denning examined the case law and further stated:109
“Collating all these cases together, I suggest that the law can be stated in
these propositions:
(1) If the election was conducted so badly that it was not substantially in
accordance with the law as to elections, the election is vitiated,
irrespective of whether the result was affected or not. That is shown by the
Hackney case, 2 O'M. & H. 77, where two out of 19 polling stations were
closed all day, and 5,000 voters were unable to vote.
(2) If the election was so conducted that it was substantially in accordance
with the law as to elections, it is not vitiated by a breach of the rules or a
mistake at the polls - provided that it did not affect the result of the
election. That is shown by the Islington case, (1901) 17 T.L.R. 210, where
14 ballot papers were issued after 8 p.m.
(3) But, even though the election was conducted substantially in
accordance with the law as to elections, nevertheless if there was a
breach of the rules or a mistake at the polls - and it did affect the result then the election is vitiated. That is shown by Gunn v. Sharpe [1974] Q.B.
808, where the mistake in not stamping 102 ballot papers did affect the
result.”
[167]
Similarly, in Edgell v Glover, Newman J stated:110
“(i) Section 48 [which re-enacted section 37(1)] is an enabling section
setting out circumstances in which, despite irregularity, a new election
need not be held;
(ii) Section 48 can be translated and understood as creating a positive
duty with the consequence that an election must be declared invalid by
reason of any act or omission of the returning officer if it appears that the
election was not so conducted as to be substantially in accordance with
the law as to elections or that the act or omission did affect the result.
(iii) The negative form of the section means that both substantial
compliance with the law and no effect upon the result are required to save
breaches of duty or the rules from voiding the election.”
109
110
At page 728.
At paragraph 23.
75
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents