stated as follows:113
“Soon after that Act was passed, Leigh and Le Marchant published a
valuable commentary on it. They transformed the negative into the
positive in the way I have suggested [Leigh & Le Marchant's Election
Law], at p. 97:
"A non-compliance with the provisions of the Ballot Act 1872,
and Schedules 1 and 2, or a mistake at the poll, will vitiate
the election, if it should appear that the result of the election
was affected thereby, but not otherwise, provided the
election was conducted in accordance with the principles laid
down in the body of the Act."
Additionally, Stephenson LJ stated in Morgan v Simpson:114
“Failures to comply with the rules or to use the right forms do not avoid an
election unless they have affected its result.”
In Marshall v Gibson, Colman J stated as follows: 115
“The effect of section 48(1) of the 1983 Act is that an election will not be
declared invalid merely because there has been a breach of official duty in
connection with the election or of the Rules by the returning officer or any
other person. There cannot be a declaration of invalidity unless it appears
either that the election was so conducted that there was substantial noncompliance with the law as to elections or that there was a breach of
official duty or of the Rules which affected the result. It is clear now that
the ‘result’ means the question which person or persons are elected as
distinct from the number of votes cast for each persons.”
[171]
In Edgell v Glover Newman J further stated:116
“Having regard to the terms of section 48(1), there should be no
declaration that the election is void or invalid unless it appears to the court
that the result was affected.”
[172]
It seems to me that more often than not, proposition (iii) would be of helpful
application in those cases in which mathematical or statistical assessment would
easily yield a determinative answer.
At page 726.
At page 729.
115 Divisional Court, 14th December 1995, (referred to in Fitch v Stephenson [2008] EWHC 501, at
paragraph 40.
116 [2003] EWHC 2566, at paragraph 25.
113
114
77
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents