Considine when he stated as follows:119
“Does it appear that the breach did not affect the result? The most
relevant facts are the following. The majority was only seven. The number
of Derringham Ward voters who received Marfleet ballot papers is not
known. Seventeen persons have made statements saying that they did
not receive ballot papers for the Derringham Ward. Another 68 voters did
not initially receive ballot papers for the ward but then applied for them
and received them. 779 voters were registered in Moorhouse Road and
Wold Road, which were the roads most affected. An unknown number of
voters did not apply for replacement papers because they understood that
they did not need to do so. I can only conclude that the breach may
well have affected the result and, therefore, that it does not appear
that it did not affect it. Section 48(1)(b) is not satisfied. So the election
must be declared void. I appreciate that this conclusion is one which is not
to be reached lightly, because, apart from other aspects, an election is an
expensive matter.” [Emphasis provided]
[181]
Newman J assessed available statistics and determined from that exercise that
the breach may well have affected the result before he concluded that it appeared
that it did not appear that the breach did not affect the result. It is from this
perspective that proposition (iv) is more accurately reflected by the following
statement:
“(iv) An election must be invalidated where it appears that the breach may
well have or probably would have affected the result and, therefore, it
does not appear that the breach did not affect the result, even though the
election was conducted substantially in accordance with the law as to
elections.”
[182]
This is a convenient juncture at which to recall the proof that a petitioner is
required to meet in order to succeed on a plea that breach of electoral law affected
the result. A good statement of this provided in Edgell v Glover, as follows:120
“… having regard to the consequences of declaring an election void, for
the court to conclude the result is affected there will need to be a
preponderance of evidence supporting that conclusion.”
Submissions
119
120
At paragraph 24 of the judgment.
[2003] EWHC 2566 (QB), at paragraph 29 of the judgment.
81
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents