either equalled or exceeded the margin of victory 502.
[198]
There is some force in Mr. Mendes’ submission that it is unrealistic to approach
the issue of invalidity on the basis that breach affected the result on the
assumption that all registered electors would have voted but for the late opening of
the polls. I understand his rationale that it is unrealistic given that the highest voter
turnout in Antigua was recorded in 2004 and no constituency has ever recorded a
turnout of 100%. An assessment based on the highest ever voter turnout in each
constituency commends itself. It provides a reliable and realistic empirical basis
for an assessment. However, out of deference for the submission by Mr. Guthrie
and Mr. Astaphan that an assessment based on a comparison between the 2009
and 2004 figures contains too many imponderables, I shall first make an
assessment assuming that 100% of the registered electors would have voted in
the 2009 elections but for the late opening of the polls.
Assessment assuming 100% voter turnout
[199]
In 2009 there were 3 polling locations in the St. George constituency. Votes were
cast as follows in the polling stations in these locations:124
Polling
Polling Station Quinn-Leandro
Jonas
Location
Rejected
Total
Total
Votes
Voted
Listed
New Winthorpes
Primary School
A – GO
208
131
2
341
GE – E
221
121
3
345
MI – Z
236
134
1
371
A–G
142
135
0
277
H–O
155
130
1
286
Piggotts Primary
124
Reproduced from Core Bundle Volume II of the Record of Appeal, page 251.
88
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents