the trial judge’s costs order.
[221]
In any event, I think that her order was a proper exercise of her discretion
exercised in accordance with principle on the basis of the relevant statute. I can
do no better than to reproduce her reasoning. She stated as follows:128
“[413] Section 61 of the Representation of People Act (as amended)
enables the Court to award costs of and incidental to the presentation of
an election petition. Section 61 of the Act stipulates:
“All costs of and incidental to the presentation of an election
petition and the proceedings consequent thereon, except such as
are by this Act otherwise provided for, shall be defrayed by the
parties to the petition in such manner and in such proportions as
the election court may determine; and in particular any costs
which in the opinion of the election court have been caused by
vexatious conduct, unfounded allegations or unfounded
objections on the part either of the Petitioner or of the respondent,
and any needless expense incurred or caused on the part of the
Petitioner or respondent, may be ordered to be defrayed by the
parties by whom it has been incurred or caused whether or not
they are on the whole successful.”
[414] It is against that background that the determination must be made as
to what is the appropriate order to do justice between the parties.
[415] The Court is cognizant of the fact that as a general rule costs follow
the event, unless there are very good reasons for the Court not to adopt
that course. The Court was provided with very helpful authorities that
indicate that the successful party, in the election petition is usually
awarded the costs. See Henry v Halstead [1991] 41 WIR at p 98.
[416] It is the law that the Court has discretion whether or not to award
costs. This discretion must be exercised judicially. Should the Court be
minded to exercise its discretion and not award the winning party its costs,
there must be some valid ground on which to buttress that exercise of
discretion.
[417] Equally, there are also cases in which our Courts have, in
appropriate cases, refrained from awarding costs to the successful litigant
in election petitions. See Ferdinand v Pinard supra, Odell Adams v
Nellie Arthurton Civil Appeal No 2 0f 1987, Montserrat, Lewis v Harris
supra. In addition, this Court in its ruling on previous applications by the
Respondents to strike out several allegations of the petition did not award
costs to the parties who had prevailed.
[418] There is no gainsaying that all of the four petitions have significant
public interest element. They also serve to provide guidance to the
128
At paragraphs 413-425 of the judgment.
98
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents