Case: 20-50407
Document: 00515441096
Page: 30
Date Filed: 06/04/2020
No. 20-50407
plaintiffs seek to prohibit General Paxton from communicating truthfully
about Texas law. And by characterizing his comments as “threats,” the district
judge undermined freedom of speech, rule of law, and the power of public
officials to participate in public discourse.
F.
The state officials likely will show that General Paxton did not threaten
the free-speech rights of these plaintiffs or anyone else. Under Texas law, it is
a crime for voters to submit knowingly false applications to vote by mail or for
third parties to encourage voters to do so. See TEX. ELEC. CODE §§ 84.0041,
276.013. Because the Texas Supreme Court interpreted “disability” not to
include lack of immunity to the Virus, In re State, 2020 Tex. LEXIS 452, at *2,
it is a crime to encourage voters to indicate that they are disabled merely
because they lack immunity.
We need not decide today whether the First Amendment allows for prosecutions based on encouraging others to submit knowingly false applications
to vote by mail. No one has been charged with a crime, and the plaintiffs do
not seek relief—declaratory or otherwise—asserting a right against such
prosecutions. 48 But what the plaintiffs do contend is that General Paxton
violated their First Amendment rights solely by expressing his professional
interpretation of the law—an interpretation that now has been vindicated by
the state’s highest civil court. To the extent that General Paxton’s comments
The plaintiffs’ proffered theory is not that they have been denied a First Amendment
right to encourage illegal activity. Instead, they suggest that it is perfectly legal under Texas
law to apply to vote by mail by citing a “disability” based only on a fear of contracting the
Virus. The Texas Supreme Court has ruled otherwise. See In re State, 2020 Tex. LEXIS 452,
at *2. Again, had the district court chosen to abstain, the issue would certainly have been
“present[ed] in a different posture”—if at all. Palmer, 617 F.2d at 428. But the court did not
abstain, and we decline to consider arguments that are not before this court and were not
presented to the district court.
48
30
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents