Case: 20-50407
Document: 00515441096
Page: 42
Date Filed: 06/04/2020
No. 20-50407
judicial consensus that “fraud is much greater in the mail-in ballot context
than with in-person voting.” Veasey, 830 F.3d at 239 (en banc).
So if Plaintiffs are entitled to relief, it is presumably the “leveling-down”
injunction noted by Texas—an injunction “requiring all to vote in person,” not
one “extend[ing] mail-in voting to those under 65.” As then-Judge Ginsburg
once put it: “[W]hich would the political branches choose? It would take a
court bolder than this one to predict . . . that extension, not invalidation, would
be the probable choice.” Olsen v. DEA, 878 F.2d 1458, 1464 (D.C. Cir. 1989).
If Plaintiffs have a legal theory to justify a “leveling-up” injunction, they
did not offer one here. Nor did the district court. So a stay is warranted. 5
***
Our charge here is simple. As the majority opinion points out, and the
Supreme Court recently reaffirmed: “[W]hen a lower court intervenes and
alters the election rules so close to the election date, our precedents indicate
that this Court, as appropriate, should correct that error.” RNC v. DNC, 140
S. Ct. 1205, 1207 (2020). The district court demonstrably erred here, and in
more ways than one—as the majority opinion extensively documents. Most
notably, the district court ignored virtually the entire body of governing
Supreme Court precedent relevant to this case, including McDonald, O’Brien,
and Morales-Santana. So the state is likely to prevail in this appeal. I concur.
Surely Plaintiffs do not want a “leveling-down” injunction—after all, depriving the
elderly of mail-in voting would seem antithetical to the spirit of their lawsuit. But it may be
the only relief courts are authorized to provide, in the event Plaintiffs ultimately prevail on
the merits of their claim. Compare, e.g., RNC v. DNC, 140 S. Ct. 1205, 1207 (2020) (“[B]y
affording relief that the plaintiffs themselves did not ask for in their preliminary injunction
motions, the District Court . . . erred.”), with Morales-Santana, 137 S. Ct. at 1701 n.29 (“That
Morales-Santana did not seek this outcome does not restrain the Court’s judgment. The issue
turns on what the legislature would have willed.”). The parties have not briefed this issue,
so I express no opinion here.
5
42
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents