something, and an effect upon voters. The Act does not preclude other types of
programme.
[86]
Second, as noted above, broadcasters must make reasonable efforts to achieve
balance within a programme or within close proximity to it. 73 This requirement has
been modified for election programmes by a code of practice issued by the
Broadcasting Standards Authority,74 but it applies to other politically controversial
programmes that do not qualify as election programmes, such as current affairs or
news programmes.
[87]
Third, the Act presumes that broadcasters control the type and content of
programmes. This suggests that for purposes of definition it is likely to be the
broadcaster’s intention for the programme that matters. Of course, this is not to
assume that the broadcaster must endorse the content.
Election programme
[88]
It follows that when characterising a programme as an election programme,
or comment, or current affairs, or news, or none of these, one must first begin by
establishing where the programme begins and ends. We recognise that an election
advertisement broadcast for a party or candidate will always be an election
programme; such advertisements are by nature discrete, in that they stand alone and
promote the advertiser’s interests, and because the Act regulates broadcasting time
bought by parties and candidates, it contemplates that advertisements will be treated
as discrete programmes. In any other case, judgment is required and the parameters
of the programme are likely to correspond to a decision made by the broadcaster.
[89]
This leads to the important point that it is the effect of the programme as a
whole that matters under s 69.
It must encourage or persuade, or appear to
encourage or persuade, voters to vote or not to vote for a party or candidate, or
advocate support for or oppose a party or candidate. In a similar vein to our point at
73
74
Section 4(1)(d) and Free-to-Air Television Code of Broadcasting Practice, above n 66, at 6 and
Radio Code of Broadcasting Practice, above n 66, at 5.
Section 79 and Broadcasting Standards Authority Election Programmes Code of Broadcasting
Practice (May 2011) at 6. The Code excludes the requirement for balance in the interests of
robust debate and advocacy, but only for election programmes as defined.