One of the specific features of the complaints procedure in Russia is the possibility
to complain not only against decisions or actions of electoral commissions and public
officials that violate citizens’ electoral rights but also against a lack of action by the
competent authorities.
Complaints against decisions, actions or omissions of electoral commissions and public
officials that violate citizens’ electoral rights go to the electoral commission above in
the hierarchy, as explained above, and it can take one of the following decisions:
a. to refuse the complaint after it has been examined;
b. to cancel the decision of the lower commission and examine the case on its merits;
and
c. to cancel the decision of the lower commission and remit the case for a fresh
examination (or take appropriate action).
c) Legislative challenges
404. Legislative electoral challenges are those legal instruments provided
for in the constitution or statutes of some countries which grant powers to
legislative bodies or other political assemblies to formally resolve certain
electoral challenges or issue the certification or the final result of an election.
405. This type of electoral challenge is considered political, not only because
of the political nature of the body in charge of resolving it, but also because
of the lack of controls to ensure that the decision concerned is always in
line with the constitution, the statute law and all other applicable provisions.
It is often political interests or negotiations between those who constitute
the majority in such assemblies that tend to prevail. The legislative organ or
political assembly in charge of resolving the case is required to conform to the
applicable constitutional and statutory framework but there may be no EDR
mechanisms to guarantee this. However, this system can be accompanied by a
judicial challenge mechanism – either as a prior remedy, as in Argentina, Italy,
Switzerland and the United States, or as a subsequent remedy, as in Germany.
This provides further guarantees that decisions are made in accordance with
the constitution and the law.
406. The means for legislative electoral challenges have come to be seen as
political, but the body responsible for resolving the challenge must operate
within the terms of the constitution and the electoral laws regardless of
whether there are mechanisms for challenging any unlawful decision before
another body. Failure to ensure this has led to abuses by some legislatures (see
paragraph 156 and box 5.3).
141
7. Basic elements of EDR systems
(cont.)