network would be picked and the details could automatically be transmitted
in seconds.
[272] As is also clear from the information posted in IEBC’s website,
among the 11,0000 polling stations IEBC claimed were off the 3G and 4G
range are in Bomet; Bungoma; Busia; Homa Bay; Kajiado; Kericho;
Kiambu; Kisumu; Kisii; Kirinyaga; Nyeri; Siaya; and Vihiga Counties. It is
common knowledge that most parts of those Counties have fairly good road
network infrastructure. Even if we were to accept that all of them are off the
3G and/or 4G network range, it would take, at most, a few hours for the
POs to travel to vantage points from where they would electronically
transmit the results. That they failed to do that is in our view, an
inexcusable contravention of Section 39(1C) of the Elections Act.
[273] We further note that at the time of declaration of results, IEBC
publicly admitted that it had not received results from 11,883 polling
stations and 17 constituency tallying centres; that in its letter of 15th August
2017, IEBC also admitted that it had not received authentic Forms 34A
from 5,015 polling stations representing upto 3.5 million votes.
[274] Dr. Aukot, the 1st interested party, in the above context echoed the
petitioners’ case that the whole process of counting, tallying and
transmission of results from polling stations to the CTC and finally to the
NTC lacked fairness and transparency. That IEBC itself admitted that it had
network problems which hindered its prompt transmission of results but by
the time of announcement of results, transmission had been completed.
Presidential
Petition
No.
1
of
2017
114
|
P a g e