Unfair Advantage:
The Abuse of State Resources in Elections
For example, for “franked” communication127 – which cannot be used to advance electoral purposes –
federal law and congressional rules prohibits mass mailings from being sent within 60 days of a Senator’s
primary or general election or nominating convention to any public office, or within 60 days of a biennial
federal general election.128 House Members may not send unsolicited mass mailings within 90 days of a
Member’s primary or general election to any public office.129 The same moratoria also applies to House
and Senate mass email communications.130
State governments in the U.S. may impose special
restrictions or moratoria on official communications
that are to be distributed to the public near the time of
an election. Alaskan law, for example, says that a state
legislator may not use state funds to print or distribute
any communication “from or about” any person who is
a candidate for federal, state, or local office within 60
days before an election.131 Nevada law imposes what is
perhaps the longest moratorium by prohibiting the use
of public funds for certain advertisements at any time
after the candidate files a declaration of candidacy.132
Excerpts from U.S. state law: New York
2. …(a) no elected government official
or candidate for elected local, state or
federal office shall knowingly appear in any
advertisement or promotion, including public
or community service announcements,
published or broadcast through any print or
electronic media (including television, radio
and internet) by any private or commercial
entity or any other entity that publishes such
advertisement for a fee, if the advertisement
or promotion is paid for or produced in
whole or in part with funds of the state,
a political subdivision thereof or a public
authority.
U.S. federal government and state governments also
impose content restrictions on official proceedings and
Public Officers Law §73-b. Advertisements by
elected government officials and candidates
communications to the public to prevent their influence
made with public funds; prohibited
on the elections. Because federal law already bars
executive branch employees from engaging in partisan
election activity on the job, which would itself cover an agency employee’s posting of partisan election
information on an agency website, information policies are principally focused on agencies’ linking to
third-party content that could possibly be of a partisan nature.133
Federal law grants Members of the House of Representatives and United States Senators the privilege to send
mail at taxpayers’ expense, provided that the mail solely pertains to the “official business, activities, and duties” of
Congress; this privilege is known as the “frank” and it facilitates communication between Members of the House
and Senate with each other, with federal and state government agencies, and with constituents. See 39 U.S.C. §
3210 (2006).
128
39 U.S.C. § 3210(a)(6)(C); see also U.S. Senate Select Comm. on Ethics, Regulations Governing the use of the
Mailing Frank by Members and Officers of The United States Senate 14-15 (2008) [hereinafter Senate Franking
Regulations].
129
39 U.S.C. § 3210(a)(6)(A). House Members may consider an individual who subscribed to a Member‘s electronic
communication or newsletter to be soliciting a response by his or her office. As a result, a communication to that
individual would not be subject to the 90-day communications ban that applies to unsolicited communications. See
House Ethics Manual, supra note 62, at 130.
130
See Franking FAQ, Committee House Admin., https://cha.house.gov/franking-commission/franking-faq (last
visited Jul. 1, 2016); see also Senate Ethics Manual, supra note 62, at 173-74.
131
Ak. Stat. § 24.60.030(c).
132
Nev. Rev. Stat. § 281A.520(2)-(4) (2009).
133
OMB requires agencies to “appropriately limit external linking [from their official websites] to information
or services necessary for the proper performance of an agency function.” Memorandum from Clay Johnson III,
Deputy Director for Management, Off. Mgmt and Budget, to the Heads of Executive Departments and Agencies,
Policies for Federal Agency Public Websites 2 (2004), available at https://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/omb/
127
memoranda/fy2005/m05-04.pdf.
17