6/25/2020
Details of 2017 (Gyo-Tsu) 47 | Judgments of the Supreme Court
principle of equality in the value of votes by the time of the ordinary
election for members of the House of Councillors scheduled in 2019.
This being true, the Election should be held unconstitutional, but it is
appropriate for the judiciary, in light of the relationship between the
legislative power and the judicial power as contemplated under the
Constitution, not to immediately conclude that the Election should be
invalidated, but to examine first the results of the correction work
with regard to which the Diet itself has promised to definitely work
toward a conclusion by 2019.
For the reasons stated above, in my opinion, the Provisions on the
Apportionment of Seats are unconstitutional, but this court should
dismiss the claim made by the appellants under the doctrine of
judgment in consideration of circumstances for the public interest,
and declare that the Election is illegal.
The dissenting opinion by Justice YAMAMOTO Tsuneyuki is as
follows.
1. Equality in the value of votes is the sole and absolute criterion
The Constitution of Japan, in its Preamble, provides that: "We, the
Japanese people, acting through our duly elected representatives in
the National Diet, […], do proclaim that sovereign power resides with
the people […] Government is a sacred trust of the people, the
authority for which is derived from the people, the powers of which
are exercised by the representatives of the people, and the benefits of
which are enjoyed by the people." Thus, it declares the principle of
sovereignty of the people under a representative democracy. Among
the three organs vested with state power, it designates the Diet as
the highest organ of state power and the sole law-making organ of
the State (Article 41).
Therefore, members of the House of Representatives and the House
of Councillors who constitute the Diet, the core of a democratic State,
must be elected by a literally fair and impartial election. This logic is
represented in Article 43, paragraph (1) of the Constitution, which
provides, "Both Houses shall consist of elected members,
representative of all the people." Of these elements, "fair election,"
which is in dispute in the present suit, is an essential constitutional
requirement. This is because unless every one of the people can
exercise their right to vote equally, the principle of sovereignty of the
people underpinned by a representative democracy, which is
advocated in the Preamble of the Constitution, would turn out to be
pie in the sky. For example, in a national election, if the value of one
vote in a particular area is a few times larger than the value of one
vote in other areas, the people in the area with votes carrying a larger
value would have greater political influence than those in areas with
votes carrying a smaller value, based on such difference in value,
which is self-evident. Under such circumstances, despite the
declaration that sovereignty resides with the people, government
established in this manner can never be described as one "the
powers of which are exercised by the representatives of the people,
and the benefits of which are enjoyed by the people."
In this sense, when assessing the provisions on the demarcation of
constituencies and apportionment of seats for a national election,
whether or not equality in the value of one vote based on the principle
of equality under the law (Article 14) is pursued would be the sole
and absolute criterion.
2. An election system causing a level of disparity larger than 20
percent is unconstitutional and void
The majority opinion states as follows: "the Constitution, at the same
time, leaves it to the Diet's discretion to decide what type of election
system should be introduced to reflect the people's interests and
https://www.courts.go.jp/app/hanrei_en/detail?id=1534
19/24
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents