6/25/2020
Details of 2017 (Gyo-Tsu) 47 | Judgments of the Supreme Court
maximum disparity between constituencies on the basis of the
population counted by the population census conducted in October
2010 became 1:2.97.
(8) On July 10, 2016, the Election was held as the first ordinary
election under the Provisions on the Apportionment of Seats. At the
time of the Election, the maximum disparity between constituencies
was 1:3.08.
3. (1) It is understood that the Constitution requires equality in the
substance of the right to vote, or in other words, equality in the
influence of votes in electing Diet members or equality in the value of
votes. However, the Constitution, at the same time, leaves it to the
Diet's discretion to decide what type of election system should be
introduced to reflect the people's interests and opinions fairly and
effectively in the political process. In view of this, equality in the value
of votes is not the sole and absolute criterion for deciding the
mechanism of the election system, but it must be realized in harmony
with other policy purposes and grounds that the Diet is authorized to
consider. Consequently, as long as a specific decision made by the
Diet can be found to be a reasonable exercise of its discretion, such a
decision cannot be held to be unconstitutional even if the decision
compromises equality in the value of votes to a certain extent.
It is understood that the Constitution adopts a bicameral system and
differentiates the House of Councillors from the House of
Representatives in terms of the scope of authority and the members'
term of office in order to have each House perform unique functions
so that the Diet can represent the people in a fair and effective
manner. From this perspective, the mechanism of the election system
for members of the House of Councillors described in Section 2(1)
above is designed to divide the members of the House of Councillors
into two groups, namely, nationally-elected members (or members to
be elected by proportional representation since the 1982 Revision)
and locally-elected members (or members to be elected by
constituency since the same revision). The former members are
elected by nation-wide constituency consisting of all prefectures,
whereas the latter members are elected by prefecture-based
constituency. At the time of the enactment of the House of
Councillors Election Act in 1947 and the enactment of the Public
Offices Election Act in 1950, the establishment of such an election
system may not be considered to have gone beyond the bounds of
reasonable exercise of the Diet's discretion. However, where extreme
inequality in the value of votes has emerged under the
abovementioned mechanism as a result of constant population
migration in this age of dramatic social and economic change, and if
the Diet has not taken any measures to correct such a level of
inequality despite its existence over a considerable period of time and
such failure to take corrective measures is regarded as going beyond
the bounds of the Diet's discretion, it would be appropriate to
construe that the relevant provisions on the apportionment of seats
have become unconstitutional.
This reasoning is in line with the series of Grand Bench Judgments on
elections of members of the House of Councillors (locally-elected
members and members elected by constituency) that have been
rendered since the 1983 Grand Bench Judgment, and the necessity to
modify this reasoning as a basic framework for determination cannot
be found.
(2) The Constitution adopts a bicameral system and guarantees the
superiority of the House of Representatives as far as certain subject
matters are concerned, while specifying the system for the House of
Councillors by providing that the term of office of members of the
House of Councillors shall be six years, that there shall be no
dissolution, and that elections shall take place for half the members
every three years (Article 46, etc.). The purpose of these provisions is
to bestow almost the same authority to the House of Councillors as
that of the House of Representatives in dealing with various subject
https://www.courts.go.jp/app/hanrei_en/detail?id=1534
7/24
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents