Cite as: 608 U. S. ____ (2026)
33
Opinion of the Court
IV
Under the updated Gingles framework, the facts of this
suit easily require affirmance.
Louisiana’s enactment of SB8 triggered strict scrutiny
because the State’s underlying goal was racial. The State
never hid the ball: It configured District 6 to achieve a black
voting-age population over 50% because it knew that if it
failed to do so, the Robinson court would very likely find its
map unlawful and order the use of something like the Robinson plaintiffs’ illustrative maps, which would have imperiled one of the influential incumbents the legislature sought
to protect. The State’s intentional compliance with the
court’s demands constituted an “express acknowledgment
that race played a role in the drawing of district lines.” Alexander, 602 U. S., at 8. Louisiana therefore had to satisfy
the “extraordinarily onerous” standard of proving that its
use of race was narrowly tailored to further a compelling
governmental interest. Id., at 11.
No compelling interest justifies SB8. Section 2 does not
provide a compelling interest because the State did not
need to create a new majority-minority district to comply
with the Act. That is because at every step of the Gingles
framework, the Robinson plaintiffs failed to prove their §2
case.
On the first Gingles precondition, the Robinson plaintiffs
did not meet their burden because they did not provide an
illustrative map that met all the State’s nonracial goals.
The most obvious deficit in the plaintiffs’ illustrative maps
was the failure to meet the State’s political goals, including
incumbency protection. The plaintiffs’ preferred map
would have placed Representative Letlow in a majorityDemocratic district and thus effectively ensured her exit
from Congress. See Brief for Appellant in No. 24–109, at
14; 2 App. to Juris. Statement in No. 24–110, p. 673a (placing Representative Letlow in a district with over twice as
many registered Democrats as registered Republicans).
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents