IN THE HONOURABLE SUPREME COURT OF REPUBLIC OF LIBERIA SITTING IN ITS OCTOBER TERM, A. D. 2017 BEFORE HIS HONOR: BEFORE HIS HONOR: BEFORE HER HONOR: BEFORE HIS HONOR: BEFORE HER HONOR: FRANCIS S. KORKPOR, SR……………..CHIEF JUSTICE KABINEH M. JA’NEH…………….ASSOCIATE JUSTICE JAMESETTA H. WOLOKOLIE.…ASSOCIATE JUSTICE PHILIP A. Z. BANKS, III………….ASSOCIATE JUSTICE SIE-A-NYENE G. YUOH………….ASSOCIATE JUSTICE The National Elections Commission ..........MOVANT/APPELLEE ) ) VERSUS ) MOTION TO ) DISMISS Charles Walker Brumskine and Harrison S. Karnwea, ) APPEAL Presidential and Vice Presidential Candidates at the ) October 10, 2017 Elections, and the Liberty Party ) …………………………………..................Respondents/1st APPELLANTS ) ) GROWING OUT OF THE CASE: ) ) Charles Walker Brumskine and Harrison S. Kamwea, ) Presidential and Vice Presidential Candidates at the ) October 10, 2017 Elections, and the Liberty Party ) ………………………………….......................................1st APPELLANTS ) ) AND ) APPEAL ) Joseph Nyumah Boakai and James Emmanuel Nuquay, ) Presidential and Vice Presidential Candidates at the ) October 10, 2017 Elections and the Unity Party, all of ) Liberia ..................................................2nd APPELLANTS ) ) VERSUS ) ) The National Elections Commission .............................APPELLEE ) ) GROWING OUT OF THE CASE ) ) Charles Walker Brumskine and Harrison S. Karnwea, ) Violation of the Presidential and Vice Presidential Candidates at the ) Constitution and October 10, 2017 Elections, All Representative ) Elections Law, Candidates of Liberty Party and the Liberty Party, ) Fraudulent Acts, all of Liberia......................................1st COMPLAINANTS )and Gross ) Irregularities AND ) During the October ) 10, 2017 Elections Joseph Nyumah Boakai and James Emmanuel Nuquay, ) Presidential and Vice Presidential Candidates at the ) October 10, 2017 Elections and the Unity Party, all of ) Liberia................................2nd COMPLAINANTS/INTERVENORS ) ) VERSUS ) ) The National Elections Commission..........................DEFENDANT ) HEARD: DECEMBER 1, 2017 DECIDED: DECEMBER 7, 2017

Select target paragraph3