Page: 56
[151] Collectively, the applicants’ uncontradicted evidence is that they regarded the
misdirecting calls as erroneous and only learned from the media coverage in February and March
case did the calls “affect the result” for the current applicants in the sense that they were
prevented from actually voting. Ms. Bielli, the applicant in the seventh and withdrawn
application, had deposed that this was the effect of the call she received.
(2)
The ITO evidence
[152] As noted above, public disclosure of Mathews’ Information to Obtain production orders
in relation to the investigation into the electoral offences in Guelph is largely responsible for
having alerted the applicants to the significance of the calls that they received. Subsequently,
another nine ITOs were disclosed as the Commissioner of Canada Elections continued his
investigation into the allegations of violations of the Act across the country.
[153] Efforts by the applicants to obtain evidence from the Commissioner and his staff with
regard to their inquiries were met with a certificate under s 37(1) of the Canada Evidence Act
asserting public interest privilege in the protection of the information on the ground, among
others, that non-disclosure was necessary to protect the integrity of the ongoing investigations.
The ITOs became public records, with redactions, following issuance and execution of the
production orders.
2013 FC 525 (CanLII)
of 2012 that the calls were likely part of an orchestrated campaign to suppress their votes. In no
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents