Page: 84
and conditions for free and fair elections. He was tendered as an expert in survey research and
[231] The respondent MPs objected to Dr. Nevitte’s evidence on the grounds that it was not
independent and objective. They argued that he was retained for the sole purpose of bolstering
the EKOS Survey, and that the admission of his evidence would split the applicants’ case. They
questioned his qualifications in expressing an opinion on voter suppression as he acknowledged
not being an expert in that field.
[232] Because of the novel use of survey evidence in this case, I considered that it was
appropriate for the applicants to seek a second opinion on the validity of the methodology and
conclusions in the EKOS Survey. I found Dr. Nevitte’s evidence to come within the Mohan
criteria. In the context of the open conflict between Graves and Corbin, I found it to be impartial
and helpful.
[233] Dr. Nevitte deposed that he had been involved in large-scale survey research dealing with
electoral data and public opinion data for 30 years. He had never seen a survey research project
that was completely free of problems. It is not unusual for survey experts to have honest
differences of opinion about the best way to conduct the research. He considered many of the
concerns raised by Dr. Corbin to be common to this kind of exchange and not requirements
observed by the industry.
2013 FC 525 (CanLII)
electoral behaviour.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents