Page: 9
[12]
The respondents are the Attorney-General of Canada, the Chief Electoral Officer of
Canada, the Returning Officers for the electoral districts, the six elected Conservative Party of
Timiskaming, Winnipeg South Centre, and Yukon), the six unsuccessful New Democratic Party
candidates, and Matt Henderson, an unsuccessful Independent candidate in Winnipeg South
Centre.
[13]
Notices of appearance were filed by each of the respondents. The respondent
Conservative MPs filed written representations and made oral submissions opposing the
applications at the hearing. The New Democratic Party candidates filed written representations
and made oral submissions in support of the applicants. The Liberal Party candidates, the
Attorney General of Canada, the Returning Officers and Mr. Henderson filed no submissions and
took no active part at the hearing. Other candidates in the several ridings did not file notices of
appearance. The Chief Electoral Officer provided written representations and oral submissions to
assist the Court with respect to the interpretation of the Act.
[14]
There were originally seven applications, but the seventh, in Court file T-616-12, Leanne
Bielli v Attorney General, was dismissed in October 2012 when it emerged that the applicant,
who had not voted due to a misleading call, had mistaken her riding and resided in an adjacent
one and not that which was the subject of her application. A motion initiated by one of the
respondents in T-616-12 and the evidence filed in that application were deemed continued in the
other six applications.
2013 FC 525 (CanLII)
Canada Members of Parliament (MPs), three unsuccessful Liberal candidates (Nipissing-
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents