Page: 51
nothing to do with the Conservative Party. The record also shows donations by Graves to Liberal
Party candidates, which, again, was within his democratic rights. The respondent MPs devoted a
matters. In my view, they did not speak directly to the question of his impartiality as a witness.
[138] When given an opportunity at the hearing to cross-examine on the substance of Graves’
sur-rebuttal affidavit, the MPs counsel persisted in focusing on the details of the modest
contributions he had given to Liberal Party candidates. They did not dwell on the contribution he
had given to a Conservative candidate. In any event, this added nothing of value to the record
that was already before the Court. I note that Graves is not alleged to have had any relationship
with the Liberal candidates in the subject ridings and he does not carry out polling for political
campaigns.
[139] The respondent MPs also alleged that Graves has a strong financial interest in the
outcome of these proceedings, in that government funding for polling by his firm was cut by
more than 80% when the Conservative Party formed the government. That appears, at first
impression, to be significant but this work, he stated, was never a major part of his business and
that assertion was not rebutted.
[140] The Supreme Court has stressed the role of trial judges in excluding unsuitable expert
witnesses: Mohan, above; R v J (J-L), 2000 SCC 51 at paras 28, 47; Dulong v Merrill Lynch
Canada Inc (2006), 80 OR (3d) 378 (SCJ) at para 9; The Federal Courts Rules, SOR/98-106,
2013 FC 525 (CanLII)
great deal of their cross-examination of Mr. Graves on his affidavit evidence to exploring these
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents