Page: 77
[215] One of the difficulties with the survey evidence, however, is that some of those who
reported having been discouraged from going to the polls had previously indicated that they had
[216] As I read the results of the survey broken down by the subject ridings, with the
percentages rounded out to avoid counting fractional people, the findings are as follows:
Winnipeg South Centre:
There were no polling station changes in this riding. The margin of victory for the
Conservative respondent was 722 votes (out of 40,093 cast for all candidates). The
survey contacted 606 people in the riding. Of those, 5.3% said that they had been called
and told that their polling station had been changed. Of those receiving such calls, 5.7%
(i.e. 1.0 percent of the 606 or 6 persons) said that they then did not vote. Extrapolating
that 1 % to the total 40,093 votes indicates that the reverse magic number (more votes
presumed to oppose the winner than the margin of victory) would not have been reached.
Saskatoon-Rosetown-Biggar:
No polling station changes. The margin of victory was 538 votes out of 30,220 cast. The
survey contacted 303 people. Of those, 4.0% (or 12 people) said that they had been called
and told that their station had been changed. Of those, 8.1% (2% of the 303 or 6 people)
said that they did not vote. Extrapolated to the total number of votes cast, 2% would
exceed the reverse magic number required.
Elmwood-Transcona:
No polling station changes. A margin of victory of 300 votes of 33,085 total cast. The
survey contacted 487 people in the riding. Of those, 4.9%, or 24 people, said that they
had been contacted about a change in their polling station. Eight people (or 1.6% of the
487) said that they then did not vote. Calculated as a percentage of the total (1.6% of
33,085), this would indicate that 529 voters did not vote, well in excess of the magic
number.
Nipissing-Timiskaming:
No polling station changes. Margin of victory for the Conservative candidate was just 18
votes out of 42,496 cast. The survey contacted 487 people in this riding. Of those, 1.8%
(or 9 people) said that they had been called with the misleading information. 12.1 %
(i.e.,1.8% of the 487, 7 people) of those said they then did not vote. Extrapolated to the
2013 FC 525 (CanLII)
in fact voted. This inherent conflict in the results was never explained to my satisfaction.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents