Page: 87
482(b), which would require proof of both a factual and a mental element. These elements would
be, they submit, 1) the utterance of a pretence or contrivance, and 2) the intent to cause an elector
either offence or those of any other electoral offence by failing to identify a perpetrator with a
guilty mind or establish that they were actually prevented from voting.
[241] The applicants submit that they have presented evidence demonstrating a prima facie
case of fraud. Telephone calls were received; these did not come from any authorized body such
as Elections Canada; they directed electors to the wrong polling stations; thousands of
complaints have been received by Elections Canada from across Canada, reflecting a countrywide pattern of conduct. The conduct was aimed at “swing ridings” such as the six that are the
subject of these proceedings, as the margin of victory in those was likely to be narrow.
[242] As I discussed above, the meaning of “fraud” in s 524(1)(b) is not limited to the
definition of any of the offences in Part 19 of the Act. It is not necessary, in my view, for an
applicant to satisfy the elements of the criminal offences in order to establish that “fraud” within
the meaning of the enactment has been made out. It is sufficient to show false representations
depriving, or creating a risk of depriving, a voter of the right to vote.
[243] I have considered whether the complainants outside Guelph conflated the calls by RMG
and media reporting and came to a mistaken conclusion that they had received deliberately
misleading calls, but this is inconsistent with the RMG evidence, which clearly shows that the
company did not make calls to non-supporters, who were identified as such in the CIMS
2013 FC 525 (CanLII)
to refrain from voting. They argue that the applicants have failed to make out the elements of
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents