Page: 49
[130] To be admissible, expert opinion evidence must meet the four part test set out in R v
Admission of expert evidence depends on the application of the following criteria:
(a) relevance;
(b) necessity in assisting the trier of fact;
(c) the absence of any exclusionary rule;
(d) a properly qualified expert.
[131] The relevance and necessity of this evidence was clear from the outset. If admitted and
given probative weight, it was capable of supporting the annulment applications. Without it, it
would have been very difficult to determine the truth of the allegations. No applicable
exclusionary rule that would prohibit reception of the evidence was drawn to my attention. The
respondent MPs’s challenge was directed, rather, at the fourth point: Mr. Graves’ qualifications
as an expert and their allegations of partiality or bias.
[132] The respondent MPs contested Mr. Graves’ qualifications for five reasons. They
contended that: he misrepresented his expertise; he and his company are documented supporters
of the Liberal Party; he has a significant adverse relationship with the respondent MPs’ party; he
has acted as an advocate for one of the parties in the case; and he failed to disclose important
facts.
[133] On the merits of the opinion, the respondent MPs retained the services of Dr. Ruth
Corbin to provide a critical analysis of the EKOS Survey and Mr. Graves’ evidence.
[134] In reply, the applicants asked Mr. Michael Adams of Environics, a competitor company
to EKOS, and Dr. Maria Barrados, former President of the Public Service Commission and
Assistant Auditor General of Canada to comment on Graves’ reputation in his field. Mr. Adams
2013 FC 525 (CanLII)
Mohan [1994] 2 SCR 9, [1994] SCJ No 36 (QL) [Mohan], at para 17:
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents