Page: 52
Rule 52.2, Schedule, Code of Conduct for Expert Witnesses and jurisprudence also speak to the
[141] The courts have drawn a distinction between the impartiality of the expert’s testimony
and the question of independence. It is not essential that the expert be independent of the party
that calls the witness so long as the opinion given is impartial: Hospira Healthcare Corporation
v Eli Lilly Canada Inc, 2010 FCA 282 at paras 8-9. The cases cited by the respondents all deal
with the objectivity of the expert’s opinion, not activities outside the retainer such as those they
have complained of in this instance: see for example Bank of Montreal v Citak, [2001] OJ No
1096 (SCJ) (QL), where the expert explicitly told the Court that "in every matter of litigation, I
always take the position of advocate for my client” (para 6).
[142] In Es-Sayyid v Canada, 2012 FCA 59 at para 43, the Federal Court of Appeal expressed
grave concerns about the objectivity of the opinion presented because of the author’s editorial
comments which were found therein – “editorial comments [. . .] using language that is
gratuitous, intemperate and ideological”. The type of blatant ideological bias that the Court
found offensive in that opinion is not found in the present matter. Rather, Graves’ opinion is
expressed in cautious terms with recognition of the limitations of the technology employed in the
survey.
[143] The respondents assert that Mr. Graves claims to be an expert in fourteen different areas,
too many for true expertise, and that his comments about the lawfulness of the telephone calls
usurp the role of the Court. I agree with the applicants that the number of areas of expertise
2013 FC 525 (CanLII)
importance of impartiality.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents