Page: 54
weaknesses of the methodology that he had validly arrived at his conclusion through a genuine
[146] In arriving at a conclusion on the admissibility of this evidence, I have not overlooked the
fact that Graves demonstrated a lack of common sense and respect for the Court when he
testified. When asked to step outside during a discussion which the Court had with counsel, he
chose to follow the live report of that discussion by journalists in the courtroom. I have reviewed
the transcript of what was said during that discussion and am satisfied that it did not have a
material effect on his testimony. As noted above, I was not persuaded that the line of crossexamination being pursued by counsel was relevant. I also recognize that Mr. Graves was given
no instruction not to access the reporters’ live transmission from the courtroom nor were the
journalists instructed not to report what was said in his absence. Nonetheless, this showed poor
judgment on Mr. Graves’ part for which he subsequently apologized to the Court.
[147] Having reviewed the arguments and the lengthy cross-examination of Mr. Graves in the
record I was not persuaded that the respondent MPs had made out a case that he was not
qualified to carry out the survey he was retained to conduct or that his opinion reflected
partiality. The respondents have not attacked Mr. Graves’s professional opinions but his personal
views and motivation in accepting the retainer. I was satisfied that he had objectively presented
the challenges and limitations of the survey methodology in his report. I find that his opinion
evidence meets the standard for admissibility set out in Mohan, above. For that reason, I dismiss
the motion to disqualify Mr. Graves and strike his evidence. I will have more to say about the
weight I have given his evidence below.
2013 FC 525 (CanLII)
analysis of the data.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents