fair elections. The legal standing required to file a
dispute with the Committee is clear: Any person
has legal standing to file a complaint regarding the
breach of the Code.21
The ECCEC comprises at least five members of
the IEBC whose Chairperson must be a person
qualified to hold the office of Judge of the High
Court.22 A person is qualified to be a High Court
Judge if he or she has been an Advocate for no
less than 10 years.23 The penalties for breaching the
Code include a formal warning; a fine; prohibition
from holding any public meetings, campaigns
or meeting voters during election period; and
ultimately, if other sanctions are not complied with,
being barred from contesting prevailing or future
elections.24 Parties who are aggrieved by the orders
of the IEBC can appeal to the High Court or challenge
the same through a judicial review process.25
In 2017, the ECCEC, while sitting in Nairobi,
entertained 71 disputes.26 Of those 71 cases, 35
cases were prosecuted and found to be in violation
of the Code, 14 were prosecuted and found not to
have been in violation of the Code, 14 cases were
dismissed for non-attendance of complainants, and
3 were withdrawn by complainants.27 Of these 71,
the High Court issued a judicial review order that
stayed the ECCEC judgment, and the remaining
three cases were dismissed by orders of the High
Court. The running themes in the disputes related
to campaigns leading to violence, plagiarism and/
or use of symbols of other candidates, independent
candidates using political party symbols or pictures,
and destruction or defacing campaign materials of
other candidates.
The Elections Act further envisions the
establishment of Peace Committees in every
constituency during an election period. These
committees are authorised to reconcile warring
parties, mediate political disputes, liaise with
government security agencies in the constituency,
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
71
disputes
35
in violation
14
not in violation
14
dismissed
report suspected election malpractices, and
report any violation of the Code to the ECCEC
for appropriate action.28 The composition of
the Peace Committee is not provided in the
Elections Act. These Committees have never
been operationalised since the enactment of the
Elections Act 2011.
OBSERVATIONS
In the run-up to the 2017 general election, the
IEBC’s orders included fines and formal warnings.29
The highest fine charged against an accused was
a cumulative Kenya Shillings 2,000,000 (approx.
$20,000) arising from two cases. Of the available
penalties, barring a political party or a candidate
from contesting elections is the harshest, and
it borders on violation of political rights. Yet a
section of Kenya’s electorate, namely women,
Elections Act 24 of 2011 Second Schedule para 19.
Elections Act 24 of 2011 Second Schedule paras 15 & 15 (2).
Constitution of Kenya art 166(5).
Elections Act 24 of 2011 Second Schedule para 7.
Republic v Independent Electoral & Boundaries Commission and Another Ex Parte Neto Adhola & Anor (2017) eKLR http://www.kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/140031/
Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission Post Election Report https://www.iebc.or.ke/uploads/resources/V9UUoGqVBK.pdf (accessed 28 February 2021).
As above.
Elections Act 24 of 2011 Second Schedule parag 17.
Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission Post Election Report https://www.iebc.or.ke/uploads/resources/V9UUoGqVBK.pdf (pg 231-237) (accessed 28 February 2021).
27
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents