original jurisdiction to entertain a dispute between a
member and a political party. This is so long as the
member showed lack of will by a political party’s
IDRM to consider a complaint in good time.62
The limits of the jurisdiction on a dispute between
a member and a political party have been tested,
giving rise to other issues that we shall explore
here.63 The PPDT entertained a complaint that
raised issue with the Jubilee Party’s list for Nairobi
City County: that the nominees were not qualified
and that the list did not reflect the ethnic diversity
of the people of Nairobi City County. The PPDT
ordered the Jubilee Party to reconstitute its Nairobi
List to reflect the ethnic diversity of the people
of Nairobi City County and be in line with the
laws. Before delving into jurisdiction, unlike the
requirements on party lists for Parliament, it should
be noted that the Constitution exempts county
assembly party lists from reflecting the regional and
ethnic diversity of Kenya.64 The PPDT’s decision
was arguably in disregard of the Constitution.
However, it may also be argued that the county list
has to reflect the community and cultural diversity
of the county.65 The High Court found that the
PPDT did not have jurisdiction to vet the nominees’
qualifications, as that is the IEBC’s role, since the
IEBC is charged with the responsibility of vetting
party lists, reviewing, accepting, or rejecting them.
66
67
68
32
IT IS GOOD LAW THAT
WHERE THE LAW HAS
ESTABLISHED A PARTICULAR
FORUM FOR REDRESS ONLY
THAT FORUM SHOULD BE
USED AND NOT ANOTHER
In a different setting, the PPDT admitted and sought
to consider a dispute seeking to unseat a sitting
member of a county assembly under the guise of
resolving a dispute between members of a political
party.66 The complaint was lodged at the PPDT after
declaration of election results and gazettement of
the respondent. The complainant claimed that the
process of nominating the respondent was flawed
and had been flouted. The PPDT remarked that it
had jurisdiction to interrogate the facts that gave
rise to the circumstances in the complaint. The
High Court asserted that even the IEBC, which has
power to adjudicate on party lists, cannot address
disputes after the election results had been
declared.67 The avenue to unseat a member of a
county assembly is through the courts.68 It is good
law that where the law has established a particular
forum for redress only that forum should be used
and not another.
Salaon v Kirui & Ors PPDT No. 2 of 2018.
Kirui & another v Salaon & another (2018) eKLR. http://www.kenyalaw.org/caselaw/cases/view/150374
Elections Act 24 of 2011 sec 75.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents