LESSONS, CHALLENGES, AND RECOMMENDATIONS
PROBLEMS WITH
INTERNAL PARTY DEMOCRACY
Ideally, political party members ought to have
access to party lists meant to be used in allocation
of special seats and the criteria used to nominate
party list members.128 Political parties are required
to abide by the democratic principles of good
governance and also promote and practise
democracy through regular, fair, and free elections
within the party.129 Nonetheless, the reality is
different as most members learn of the content of
party lists only when the IBC publishes them in the
newspapers.130 This means that their opportunity
to interrogate the lists is limited. Besides, the
prerogative to list nominees lies with the party,
except when the priority of nominees has been
prescribed by the law. An aggrieved member
cannot therefore demand to be listed in a certain
position and neither the IEBC nor the PPDT has
power to dictate the priority of nominees on a list
yet this forms part of the pre-election disputes.
all commissioners should have at least two years’
experience before every election.131 Electoral
amendments should also be put into effect at least
two years before a general election.
INEFFECTIVE REMEDIES
It is not in a complainant’s interest to obtain a
remedy that is unenforceable due to the framing
of the order or lapse of time. The PPDT made
judgments that included instructing the IEBC to
include aggrieved persons on party lists, yet this
is not within the mandate of the IEBC, but that of
the political parties. There was occasion where the
orders of the PPDT were time barred, and hence of
no benefit to complainants. It is necessary to review
EDR timelines and the courts to ensure the apt
framing of orders. Further, there is need for limiting
appellate stages with respect to appeals from IEBC
and PPDT, to avoid a scenario of orders that cannot
be implemented.
ADJUDICATION IN ABSENTIA
ELECTORAL AMENDMENTS
Timely change in laws allows stakeholders,
partners, and everyone in general to acquaint
themselves with the duties and privileges under the
law. This aids in effective and practical enforcement
of the law. Late amendments, as was the case
regarding vetting of political party nomination rules,
defeat the law’s purpose. A timely amendment
includes respect for the principles of the
Constitution on elections, thereby limiting undue
advantage to any of the parties. Further, persons
charged with the duty to enforce newly enacted
laws require time to acquaint themselves with them.
The Report of the Independent Review Commission
on the 2007 general election recommended that
128
129
130
131
Resolution of disputes must be in open court.
The open justice principle means that court
proceedings should be conducted publicly or in an
area to which litigants and members of the public
have access and can be present if they so wish.132
This is a pillar of transparency. On the other hand,
hearings need not be in person, as long as no real
or perceived risk is posed towards the rights of
the parties; a party should, however, be notified
and have a chance to file pleadings in support
of their case even when they do not appear in
person. Courts have observed that bodies whose
procedures are laid down by statute are masters
of their own procedure, provided they achieve the
degree of fairness appropriate to their task. It is
Constitution of Kenya art 35 & Elections (Party Primaries and Party Lists) Regulations, 2017 regulation 5 (c).
Constitution of Kenya art 91 (1) (d).
Elections (General) Regulations, 2012 regulation 54(8).
At http://kenyalaw.org/kl/fileadmin/CommissionReports/Report-of-the-Independent-Review-Commission-on-the-General-Elections-held-in-Kenya-on-27th-December-2007.pdf
(accessed 20 February 2021).
132 International Foundation for Electoral Systems ‘Elections on Trial: The Effective Management of Election Disputes and Violations’ May 2018 https://www.ifes.org/sites/default/files/
ifes_managing_electoral_disputes_and_violations_final.pdf (accessed 14 May 2020).
40
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents