the language used that excludes sign language
and Braille or the arena of action that is unsafe for
persons who require accessibility accommodations,
or the loss of the secrecy of the vote for voters
needing assistance. In Mateta v ZEC & Others,25 the
applicant sought to have the respondent compelled
to print ballot papers in Braille or to provide a
template ballot or other tactile voting devices and
make them available for use by him and other
voters with visual disabilities who wished to vote
by secret ballot in the 2018 general election. The
High Court dismissed the case on the ground that
Braille literacy levels are low and because the ZEC
allowed assisted voting by a person of the voter’s
choice. This case shows how sometimes neither the
legislation nor the courts will take the extra steps
needed to ensure inclusion of marginalised groups
on equitable terms.
PARTICIPATION OF PERSONS IN PLACES
OF DETENTION AND INCARCERATION
There is another group traditionally discriminated
against, as they are alleged to be responsible
for their condition. These are people in prisons.
In many jurisdictions, convicted prisoners are
disenfranchised. As an automatic consequence
of their convictions and detention pursuant to
sentences of imprisonment, prisoners lose their
liberty, which consequently includes the liberty to
participate in any civic activities. Some jurisdictions
permit voting by prisoners with lesser sentences, or
by remand prisoners awaiting trial.
This was the case with the Zimbabwean
opposition activists, Tungamirai Madzokere and
Last Maengahama, who petitioned the court
demanding that they be allowed to exercise their
voting rights.26 In their application, the convicted
prisoners were seeking an order compelling the
Justice, Legal and Parliamentary Affairs Minister
and the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission (ZEC)
to register them on the national voters’ roll and
facilitate their voting on election day. It took more
than a year for their case to reach the stage of
25
26
27
28
a hearing, which took place two weeks before
election day. The court reserved judgment in
the matter, meaning that they were effectively
disenfranchised.27 Experts28 have argued that
although Zimbabwe’s previous Constitution, the
Lancaster House Constitution, denied the right to
vote to prisoners serving sentences of more than
six months, the present Constitution contains
no such exclusion. Therefore, prisoners should
have the same right as all other citizens to vote
in elections. Although the courts have not ruled
conclusively on this matter, in practice, prisoners
have been blocked from participating in elections.
Zimbabwe’s election management body, the ZEC,
has not provided prisoners with logistics to ensure
that they, too, may register. As a result, prisoners
were disenfranchised in the 2018 elections.
South African and Ugandan case law offer an
interesting progressive perspective. In the
August case29 in South Africa, the applicants
sought confirmation from the Constitutional Court
that prisoners did indeed have the right to vote
in the election. The applicants argued that the
Independent Electoral Commission (IEC) had a
duty to facilitate the voter registration of prisoners
who were unable to register due to their
imprisonment. The IEC had refused to undertake
this responsibility unless ordered to do so by
the Constitutional Court, since prisoners were
viewed as “authors of their own misfortunes.” In
addition, it was argued that numerous logistical
arrangements would have to be undertaken to
register the prisoners. The Court relied on the
provision of the Constitution that South Africa is,
amongst others, founded on the value of universal
adult suffrage and ruled that in the absence of
any legislative disenfranchisement, prisoners
retained their constitutional right to vote. The IEC
was ordered to make all reasonable arrangements
to enable prisoners to register and to vote. The
Court stated “[T]he universality of the franchise is
important not only for nationhood and democracy.
The vote of each and every citizen is a badge of
dignity and personhood.”
HC 4349/18.
SC 8/12.
Kubatana, ‘Zim Court Hears Prisoners’ Petition to Vote’, July 2018.
Veritas, Election Watch 18 of 2018. https://www.veritaszim.net/node/2431.
55
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents