The Court went on to point out that South African
citizens abroad benefited the country through
remittances and in other ways. The Court also
referred to a survey in which it was found that 115
countries made provision for voting by absent
voters and only 14 restricted their entitlement to
vote on the basis of activity undertaken abroad
by the absent voters. The Court emphasised the
importance of exercising the right to vote: “[E]ach
vote strengthens and invigorates our democracy. In
marking their ballots, citizens remind those elected
that their position is based on the will of the people
and will remain subject to that will.”
STEPS TOWARDS INCLUSION
Electoral laws need to be written and interpreted
to promote inclusion rather than exclusion of
voters. All the groups discussed in this section
are marginalised groups. In the Electoral Institute
for Sustainable Democracy in Africa’s report on
Promoting Inclusive Elections, AnaSofia Bizos writes
that if African democracies are to be resilient and
truly representative, vulnerable and marginalised
groups must be enabled and encouraged to
participate in the political processes of their home
country, whether through the electoral process,
governance or civil society.35 The judiciary can play
barriers for participation of women. Recently,
Zimbabwe approved principles for the
transformation of the prison system towards a
more human rights-centred approach, giving hope
of positive traction in that direction. Where the
executive is keen to place administrative obstacles
in the way, the judiciary is encouraged to take a
pro-human rights approach.
The cases in South Africa and Zimbabwe discussed
above show that there is a need, ahead of the
elections, to develop measures to ensure that
marginalised groups are part of the political
process. Although there is no argument being
made against the participation of women and
persons with disabilities, key challenges emerge
on the diaspora and the persons in detention. The
gaps between the Zimbabwean and the South
African approaches can be bridged by paying
attention to the regional standards. The excuse
of limited resources should never be used to
disenfranchise anyone, as the cost of a polarised
society is much more devastating than the cost
of enabling participation. The African Charter on
Democracy, Elections, and Governance obliges
state parties to recognise popular participation
through universal suffrage as the inalienable right
of the people.
a progressive role in facilitating such a role.
ELECTORAL LAWS NEED
TO BE WRITTEN AND
INTERPRETED TO PROMOTE
INCLUSION RATHER THAN
EXCLUSION OF VOTERS
The South African case law shows a different
approach to the issue of promoting inclusive
participation. More and more countries are
developing approaches to recognise the rights
of persons in detention and the participation of
persons with disabilities, as well as overcoming
34
35
36
58
PERSONAL SECURITY
AND DEMOCRATIC PARTICIPATION
One issue that affects democratic participation
is the question of personal security. In many
countries, the pre-election period is characterised
by violence and intimidation. Indeed, in some
countries, elections are an act of war. Instead
of delivering hopeful joy and expectation, they
deliver fear and dead bodies. With a long legacy
of violence, there is a lot of intimidation of voters
and rivals. Exorcising the pre-election environment
requires investments in strengthening the rule
of law and combatting impunity. The trend in
countries like Zimbabwe has been to undermine
the rule of law by granting amnesty to perpetrators
of political violence after every election.36 This
Richter v The Minister for Home Affairs and Others, [2009] ZACC 3.
A Bizos ‘Introduction, in Promoting Inclusive Elections, 2017’ Electoral Institute for Sustainable Democracy in Africa https://www.eisa.org.za/pdf/symp2016paper2.pdf.p.5.
A Magaisa ‘A Short History of Impunity and Political Violence in Zimbabwe’ The Big Saturday Read https://www.bigsr.co.uk/single-post/2016/04/22/The-Big-Saturday-ReadPresidential-Amnesty-A-short-history-of-impunity-and-political-violence-in-Zimbabwe.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents