INTRODUCTION
It has been stated that an election is not an event
but a process or continuum that commences from
registration of voters to declaration of results.1 This
means that the pre-election period is as important
as the voting itself. This is precisely because the
voting process and the outcome of voting are
a function of events that precede such voting.
For instance, eligible voters who have not been
registered as voters by the relevant electoral
body and issued with voting cards cannot cast
votes for their preferred candidates, however
much they desire. Similarly, aspiring candidates
for various electoral positions who have not been
nominated by their political party or approved by
the electoral body as independent candidates, as
the case may be, cannot validly be elected into
any elective office. Well aware of this fact, various
players and political opponents do everything
in their power to ensure that these pre-election
processes are interfered with in their favour so
as to disenfranchise a political opponent or the
opponent’s supporters. This state of affairs also
accounts for a significant number of pre-election
disputes reaching dispute resolution forums in
Kenya, including the electoral body, the Political
Parties Dispute Tribunal, and the election court in
the form of election petitions.
One of the areas that has been the subject of many
pre-election disputes is nominations. Nominations
have been defined as “a process through which
candidates are identified for participation in an
election, subject to them being properly qualified
under the law, for the elective seat that they
seek.”2 In this regard, nominations are of two kinds:
one of them refers to internal party nomination
process, in which aspiring candidates compete
for a political party’s ticket, while the one refers
to registration by the electoral body to run for
elective office. In this chapter, we apply the term
nomination rather interchangeably to refer to both
of these processes as the case may be. Suffice it
to state that nominations are a critical component
of the electoral process and must occur before
any election can take place and are thus a central
tenet of free and fair elections in a constitutional
democracy. Indeed, the Constitution of Kenya
provides that a presidential election stands
cancelled if no candidate is nominated before the
prescribed statutory period for filing of nomination
papers.3 The Constitution avails a framework
This chapter assesses emerging jurisprudence from
Kenyan courts and other dispute resolution forums
on resolution of disputes in the pre-election period.
These disputes, among others, take the form of
disputes in relation to, or arising from, political party
nominations; eligibility of voters and candidates to
run for office; instances of electoral malpractice,
including voter bribery and violence before
and a yardstick within which nominations before
elections are conducted. This is by providing for
qualifications and disqualifications for nomination
of candidates. Disputes commonly arise at the
nomination stage within political parties, given
the critical place and role that nominations play
especially in a society with “ethnicised” political
parties4 and an ethnically-stratified voting class
like Kenya.5 The stakes are high in this context;
1
2
3
4
5
64
elections or during nominations; and whether a
candidate has met the qualification criteria set in
law to contest for a particular elected office.
Sammy Ndung’u Waity v Independent Electoral & Boundaries Commission & 3 others [2019] eKLR para 61. Also see, Judiciary Working Committee on Election Preparations, ‘Pre-election
Dispute Management: Between Judicial and Administrative Dispute Management Mechanisms’ (September 2012) <http://kenyalaw.org/kl/index.php?id=1902> (accessed on 12 April 2020).
See the Supreme Court decision, John Harun Mwau & 2 others v Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission & 2 others [2017] eKLR para 234.
Constitution of Kenya 2010, art. 138(8) a.
S Elischer, ‘Ethnic Coalitions of Convenience and Commitment: Political Parties and Party Systems in Kenya’ (2008) GIGA Working Papers 68/2008 < https://core.ac.uk/download/
pdf/6862963.pdf> (accessed on 14 December 2019); Karuti Kanyinga, Kenya: Democracy and Political Participation (AfriMAP, Open Society Initiative for Eastern Africa, and the
Institute for Development Studies, University of Nairobi, March 2014) 20.
F Holmquist & Mwangi wa Githinji, ‘The Default Politics of Ethnicity in Kenya’ (2009) 16(1) The Brown Journal of World Affairs 101. Here, the authors argue that the 2007-8 postelection violence in Kenya demonstrated the ethnic nature of the electorate’s political identities and that the political class was divided on ethnic terms almost leading to state
collapse. See also, Kenya Human Rights Commission, Ethnicity and Politicization in Kenya (KHRC: Nairobi, May 2018) <https://www.khrc.or.ke/publications/183-ethnicity-andpoliticization-in-kenya/file.html> (accessed on 15 December 2019); Karen E Ferree, Clark C Gibson & James D Long, ‘Voting behaviour and electoral irregularities in Kenya’s 2013
Election’ (2014) 8(1) Journal of Eastern African Studies 153, 155.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents