This confidence will speedily be destroyed, if,
after the heat and excitement of a contested
election, a judge is to proceed to the scene of
recent conflict, while men’s passions are still
roused… The decision of the judge given under
such circumstances will too often fail to secure
the respect, which judicial decisions command
on other occasions. Angry and excited partisans
will not be unlikely to question the motives, which
have led to the judgment. Their sentiments may
be echoed by the press. Such is the influence of
party conflict that it is apt to inspire distrust and
dislike of whatever interferes with party objects
and party triumphs.
The “legal transplant” of the election petition
procedure from parliament to courts presented
an enduring “fundamental design problem.”8 The
adversarial inquiry into proceedings does not
do much to help the court establish the truth as
compared to the inquisitorial procedure in which
the court participates in the proceedings by directly
interrogating the adduced evidence. Judges
have expressed an unwillingness to interfere
with election results in most if not all presidential
election petitions cases in Africa, with a few
exceptions being decided “in favour of the status
quo and many cases dismissed on flimsy technical
and procedural rules.”9
JUDGES HAVE EXPRESSED
AN UNWILLINGNESS TO
INTERFERE WITH ELECTION
RESULTS IN MOST IF
NOT ALL PRESIDENTIAL
ELECTION PETITIONS
CASES IN AFRICA,
WITH A FEW EXCEPTIONS
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
The past years have witnessed a rise in the number
of electoral disputes in African courts, including
presidential election petitions. As a Ghanaian court
held in Akuffo-Addo v Mahama (Akuffo-Addo case):
Elections are complex systems designed and
run by fallible humans. Thus, it is not surprising
that mistakes, errors, or some other imperfection
occurs during an election. Because absolute
electoral perfection is unlikely and because
finality and stability are important values, not
every error, imperfection, or combination of
problems supports an election contest, voids the
election, or changes its outcome. This court must
spend some time to determine whether votes
affected by minor irregularities are nonetheless
valid, and if so, separating them from the votes
that are invalid because they are tainted by more
serious irregularities.10
Accordingly, courts are called to perform, “the
unenviable task of determining the ultimate
outcome of the poll.”11 Challenging the validity
of an election is essentially an act of democratic
self-government meant to ensure free, fair, and
credible elections.12 Preservation of electoral
intent and purity of elections hinges on the
effective management of the electoral process,
failing which there should be fair adjudication of
electoral grievances. Electoral dispute resolution
(EDR) or electoral justice is one of the areas
where international law offers limited guidance.
International law defers to national authorities to
adopt electoral systems of their choice, with the
condition precedent that such electoral systems
should be capable of delivering an election that
reflects the free will of voters.13
African countries south of the Sahara have
adopted diverse electoral and political systems.
However, a common feature is the settlement of
electoral disputes in the courts of law, even though
specific aspects of the adjudication process may
vary.14 Another common feature is that EDR is an
C O’Leary ‘The Elimination of Corrupt Practices in British Elections’ 1868-1911 (1961) 4.
O Kaaba ‘The challenges of adjudicating presidential election disputes in domestic courts in Africa’ (2015) 15. African Human Rights Law Journal 329-354 at p329.
Akuffo-Addo v Mahama Writ No. J1/6/2013, 29th August, 2013, 519. https://ghalii.org/gh/judgment/supreme-court/2013/3 (accessed on 15 May 2020).
O Kaaba (n 5).
Tsvangirai v Mugabe & Ors Judgment No. CCZ 1/17 10.
General Comment No. 25, United National Human Rights Committee, para 20.
C O’Leary (n 122) 4.
85
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents