creates a vicious cycle of violence, in which the
entire electoral cycle becomes poisoned by chronic
violence. Courts can help break this vicious cycle
by ensuring that perpetrators of violence do not
enjoy its fruits in the form of election victory.
Combating the outbreak of election-related
violence is fundamental to a country’s long-term
peace and stability. This process is complex, as
it requires trust building and multi-stakeholder
involvement. Addressing violence comprehensively
means addressing all its forms, including threats
and hate speech as well as physical violence, and
its root causes as well as structural and cultural
violence. Such an approach should bring in key
actors including media, security sector, political
parties, civil society, as well as law enforcement and
the judiciary.
It has been argued that violence in the pre-election
environment can influence the electoral outcome.
This is more so where the violence is systematic.
In Zimbabwe, the opposition candidate Morgan
Tsvangirai in the Buhera North Election Petition
(HH 67/2001) argued that statements made by
the President, the Chairman of the War Veterans
Association, and then Minister of Defence, Moven
Mahachi had unduly influenced the outcome of
the election and set the campaign of violence in
motion. The Court, however, adopted a narrow
interpretation in the matter, refusing to accept as
evidence press reports to the effect of the violence
on the electoral outcome. This approach has been
criticised by human rights groups who argue that
cases of such importance as electoral challenges,
where there were damning testimonies of gross
human rights violations, cry for active and brave
judges. The judges must be ready and willing to
develop the country’s human rights jurisprudence
so that it keeps in step with international
standards.37 The result has been the creation of a
culture where political violence goes unchecked,
and intimidation becomes a tool for campaigning,
leaving the ordinary people vulnerable. In
Zimbabwe, this has been cemented by the passage
of a series of amnesty laws meant to protect law
37
38
39
40
enforcement agencies from being held accountable
for pre-election violence.
In the case of South Africa since 1994, elections
have generally been peaceful until the formation of
the Congress of the People (COPE) threatened the
monopoly of the African National Congress (ANC).38
From 1994, intimidation resurfaced in South African
elections in various ways. Bruce39 documents
various forms of intimidation and manipulation in
South African elections. These come in the form
of vote buying, manipulation of food aid, denial of
access to venues, disruption of meetings, violence
and threats of physical harm, damage to property
and denial of jobs and contracts beyond the
election day. Bruce reports that police responses
were generally ineffectual.40 Not many cases have
been brought to the courts on this basis.
In Zimbabwe, several cases have been brought
to the courts alleging that election-related
violence influenced an electoral outcome. Many
of these cases have however, been decided on a
technicality, denying the country an opportunity to
develop electoral jurisprudence on the impact of
violence on an election. In a recent Zimbabwean
case, Chamisa and 24 Others v Emmerson
Mnangagwa,41 the opposition leader Nelson
Chamisa raised allegations of undue influence,
threats, injury, damage, harm or loss to voters, bribery
and manipulation of food aid. These were alleged to
have affected the integrity of the election.
In dismissing the application, the Constitutional
Court adopted the following principles:
Where the grounds for challenging the validity of
an election result are allegations of irregularities
committed by officers of the body charged with
the responsibility of conducting the election or
electoral malpractices committed by others who
took part in the election process, the duty of a
court is to satisfy itself by sufficient and clear
evidence produced by the party bearing the
onus of proof of the allegation that the alleged
acts occurred. If a court finds as a matter of fact
Zimbabwe Human Rights NGO Forum ‘Organised Violence and Torture in Zimbabwe in 2001’ 2001 http://hrforumzim.org/wp-content/uploads/2010/06/Torture_Report_2001.pdf.
D Bruce ‘Just singing and dancing? Intimidation and the manipulation of voters and the electoral process in the build-up to the 2014 elections’ Community Agency for Social
Enquiry (CASE) (2014).
As above.
As above 4.
59
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents