this by taking control of the electoral body and the
procuring of election materials and technology.69
Indeed, these concerns are not idle, as interference
with procuring of ballot materials or technology
used for voting or transmission of results can
significantly compromise final election results.
IEBC’s Information Communication Technology
(ICT) manager was killed a few weeks before
the elections, yet he was the one in charging of
securing the servers and electronic system, which
gave these concerns more currency. This was
coupled with allegations of possible tampering
with the IEBC’s servers. It is also worth noting that
the ensuing presidential election petition that was
annulled had the issue of technology as one of the
main issues being litigated.70
IT IS ALSO WORTH NOTING
THAT THE ENSUING
PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION
PETITION THAT WAS
ANNULLED HAD THE
ISSUE OF TECHNOLOGY
AS ONE OF THE MAIN
ISSUES BEING LITIGATED
TIMELINES FOR RESOLUTION
OF PRE-ELECTION DISPUTES
It needs be stated that the pre-election dispute
resolution bodies acquitted themselves remarkably
well in the period leading to the 2017 General
Elections. The judiciary received more than 845
pre-election disputes, with the vast majority of them
69
70
71
72
73
78
finalised within three weeks.71 However, in the runup to the 2017 general elections, there were cases
of some pre-election disputes being resolved late
in the day or so close to polling day that they were
nearly impossible or impracticable to implement.
For instance, there were incidences of disqualified
candidates being reinstated by pre-election dispute
resolution bodies after ballot papers had already
been printed and technological devices such as the
Kenya Integrated Electoral Management System
already having been procured. Equally, there was
also a nullification of the decision of the electoral
body to procure election materials from a company
named Al Ghurair. This was on account of lack of
public participation on 7 July 2017, with the court
ordering the electoral body to restart the tendering
process exactly a month to elections which were
scheduled for 8th August 2017.72 This decision
was reversed on 20 July 2017 by the Court of
Appeal, which stated there was no need for public
participation in direct procurement,73 with the result
that the electoral body resumed ballot printing only
18 days before Election Day. These difficulties arose
largely because the law has not set any timelines
within which election courts must resolve preelection disputes. It should, however, be noted that
Section 41(1) of the Political Parties Act requires the
Political Parties Dispute Tribunal to resolve preelection disputes within three months.
THESE DIFFICULTIES AROSE
LARGELY BECAUSE THE LAW
HAS NOT SET ANY TIMELINES
WITHIN WHICH ELECTION
COURTS MUST RESOLVE
PRE-ELECTION DISPUTES
This indeed informed the petition by the opposition in National Super Alliance (NASA) Kenya v The Independent Electoral & Boundaries Commission & 2 Others, Nairobi High
Court Petition No. 328 of 2017 where the petitioner unsuccessfully sought to have identification of voters and transmission of results after learning that the electoral body had
not procured the required technology and tested it prior to elections. The Court, in a decision further affirmed on appeal, while acknowledging that there is provision for use of
technology in elections held that the same was not mandatory but was to serve as a complementary mechanism when the system failed.
See, Raila Odinga & Another v IEBC & 2 Others, Presidential Election Petition 1 of 2017.
Election Union Election Observation Mission, Republic of Kenya, Democratic commitment demonstrated by the people of Kenya, despite parties’ forceful criticism of key
institutions, Preliminary Statement issued on 10 August 2017, 5. <https://reliefweb.int/sites/reliefweb.int/files/resources/eu_eom_kenya_2017_preliminary_statement_final.pdf>
accessed on 07 July 2020; EU EOM (n 59 above) 15.
Republic v Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission (I.E.B.C.) Ex parte National Super Alliance (NASA) Kenya & 6 others [2017] eKLR, Judicial Review 378 of 2017.
Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission (IEBC) v National Super Alliance (NASA) Kenya & 6 others [2017] eKLR, Civil Appeal No. 224 of 2017.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents