ROLE OF INTERNAL DISPUTE RESOLUTION MECHANISM Every political party is required to have an internal dispute resolution mechanism (IDRM).69 The Political Parties Act envisages the IDRM hearing and determining disputes within parties (between members, or between a member and his or her party), such as the development of party lists, and also disputes between parties. It is also possible for the IDRM to determine disputes on party primaries.70 The Elections Act demands that an IDRM is supposed to hear and determine all intraparty disputes arising from political party nominations within 30 days.71 The Elections (Party Primaries and Party Lists) Regulations of 2017 categorically requires an IDRM’s adjudication to respect rules of natural justice.72 IDRM decisions may be appealed to the PPDT, and from there to the High Court on points of law, and on facts then on points of law to both the Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court.73 Although political parties have the duty to address nomination disputes internally before aggrieved members seek audience elsewhere, this has not always been the case, as some parties have not appreciated the role and essentials of IDRM.74 This includes lack of a properly established organ on dispute resolution, frustration of the adjudication process by some party organs in terms of delays, and outright non-compliance with rules of natural justice. As a result, aggrieved party members approach the PPDT directly, which is legally apt, because the Tribunal has original jurisdiction on party primaries.75 This, however, builds up to dysfunctional internal party mechanisms on resolving disputes. A functional and effective IDRM contributes to timely resolution of disputes, which will have further effect on the workload and nature of disputes filed at PPDT or IEBC. Political parties cannot execute sound dispute resolution if their foundation is not aligned with democracy and ideals of good governance. A 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 party with limited intra-party democracy cannot be expected to resolve disputes fairly. For instance, rules of all political parties in Kenya provide for use of direct nomination in certain situations. The proviso is intended to protect the overall interests of the party, including avoiding the financial cost of conducting a party primary, where there is only one person interested in the nomination. Where there are competing interests among party members, the use of direct nomination becomes a trigger of conflict, as it contains an aspect of favouritism. Parties need clear rules on when to employ alternative nomination methods like direct nomination. A person aggrieved by his or her party for using direct nomination cannot possibly have faith in the party organs to address his or her complaint unless detailed rules exist to instil fairness. Where the general interaction and compliance of parties with existing laws is below par, the conduct of parties cannot be above par. “Above par” means effective participation of minorities and traditionally excluded groups in decision-making organs as opposed to performative inclusion, participation of members in formulating party rules, and powers of the party leaders as juxtaposed with other party members. Along these lines, reimagining the advent of parties in Kenya offers counsel on reforming parties on the aspects which will subsequently have an effect on IDRM. How did multi-party democracy become actualised in Kenya? The response to this question shows that there has been a negligible difference between practical intra-party democracy in the parties before and after enactment of the Political Parties Act of 2011. A reform agenda that seeks to reform flawed components of parties that were founded on personal interests and not democracy is bound to fail. Honest interrogation of history is therefore significant in ensuring that parties operate within the confines of the law — including the establishment and operationalisation of IDRM. Political Parties Act No. 11 of 2011 Second Schedule para 23. Political Parties Act 11 of 2011 sec 40. Elections Act 24 of 2011 sec 13 (2A). Elections (Party Primaries and Party Lists) Regulations L.N. 69/2017 Regulation 27(1) & 27(3). Political Parties Act 11 of 2011 sec 41 (2). https://www.undp.org/content/dam/kenya/docs/Democratic%20Governance/Final%20SOURCE%20BOOK%20%201ST%20NOVEMBER%2016%20(003).pdf (accessed 1 April 2020). Political Parties Act 11 of 2011 sec 40(2). 33

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents