the public. Its suitability was further buttressed
by existing ramps and wide doors to enable ease
of movement by persons using wheelchairs and
crutches. It is a best practice principle for courts
to be accessible to everyone, including persons
with disabilities.
• Legal awareness:
IEBC Commissioners and select staff were taken
through a two-part course on EDR under the
guidance of the International Foundation for
Electoral Systems (IFES). The first leg was from 28
March 2017 to 1 April 2017 and the second was
7 to 8 April 2017. The substance of the training
included International Standards for an effective
election dispute resolution mechanism. Among
the standards of focus were a transparent right of
redress, clearly defined election standards and
procedures, an impartial and informed arbiter,
a system that judicially expedites decisions,
established burdens of proof and standards of
evidence, meaningful and effective remedies,
effective education of stakeholders, conduct of
hearings, and contents of decisions. In addition,
the sessions included simulation of cases. This
calibre of exercise ought to be continuous and
not pegged on an EDR period.
IDRM AND PEACE COMMITTEES
Strengthening and comprehensive
operationalisation of IDRM and Peace Committees
established under Para. 17 of the Second Schedule
to the Elections Act are opportunities that ought to
be harnessed.
A functional IDRM includes a dispute resolution
panel that appreciates not only the electoral laws
but also salient principles of natural justice. In
addition, party constitutions and rules ought to
have elaborate provisions on dispute resolution
with clear timelines. There ought to be a penalty
for parties which frustrate members from accessing
justice within the party. It is nevertheless probable
that not all parties can afford to hire personnel
with a legal background or appreciate democracy-
related issues. The IEBC and ORPP therefore have
a gap to fill through offering training. A component
of the Political Parties Fund may be redirected to
building the capacity of parties on dispute resolution.
THERE OUGHT TO BE A
PENALTY FOR PARTIES
WHICH FRUSTRATE MEMBERS
FROM ACCESSING JUSTICE
WITHIN THE PARTY
Peace Committees, on the other hand, are the
grassroots level of adjudicating disputes. Different
electoral areas are likely to have different triggers
of violence or conflict. Rather than having IEBC
address such issues at the headquarters level, a
community-owned structure is more likely to be
efficient. There is a need for the communities to
have the ownership of the structure in terms of
the composition including community leaders.
To borrow a leaf from the sexual and genderbased violence cases in Kenya with respect to
the role of community structures, some cases
are not settled within the formal legal system but
adjudicated upon by community elders.135 However,
regarding elections, dynamics of different areas
could be used to determine the composition of
peace committees.
Addressing issues at the grassroots level has the
potential to reduce strain on the IEBC and the
PPDT, hence overall efficiency.
LEGISLATIVE INTERVENTIONS
PLATFORM CERTAINTY
The blank cheque that allows complainants to
lodge certain categories of complaints at either
the PPDT or the IEBC is not beneficial as it creates
inconsistency and uncertainty in terms of the orders
issued. In addition, depending on the perception of
litigants, one of the bodies is bound to be rendered
135 J Guyo & G Mwangi ’An Assessment of Sexual and Gender Based Violence in Wajir district, North Eastern Kenya Eastern Kenya’ (2009) https://www.researchgate.net/deref/
http%3A%2F%2Fdx.doi.org%2F10.13140%2F2.1.3519.2007 (accessed 1 March 2021).
42
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents