In this case, applicants approached the court
alleging, inter alia, that the state broadcaster’s
coverage of political parties was heavily biased in
favour of the ruling party, in violation of provisions
of the Constitution requiring impartiality by stateowned media. The Court found the conduct of
the state broadcaster and state newspapers to
be in material breach of the Constitution because
they had not been impartial and free to determine
the content of their broadcast. The court also
held that the respondents had not afforded fair
opportunity for presentation of divergent views
and dissenting opinions. The Court noted that
opinion pieces, especially in the print media,
disgorge hate and inflammatory language, and
ordered state media to exercise impartiality and
independence in their editorial content. The
Court also had this to say:
The respondents are all critical players in any
plebiscite. By the powers reposed and vested
in them by law and social contract, they can
individually or collectively make or break an
election. They can foster democracy or stifle it.
The framers of our constitution and our parliament
were quite conscious of the need, among others,
to safeguard multi-party democracy and combat
one-party state governance.14
Although the judgment came out a year after
the elections, it sets out important principles
about the conduct of public media. It emphasises
the importance of information management, as
this determines how people may act and the
perceptions that affect how the electorate will
decide. This matter becomes more important in
countries where there is no media plurality and the
public depend on the information provided by the
state media to make decisions.
However, there is another aspect of information
management that needs to be understood.
Although the Veritas case was about coverage,
there is also the issue of disclosure. While
coverage relates to general coverage of issues and
14
15
16
17
18
19
candidates, disclosure is about candidates being
transparent about their funding, allegiances, and
loyalties. A South African case makes this clear.
In My Vote Counts v Minister of Justice and
Correctional Services,15 it was declared that
information on the private funding of political
parties and independent candidates is essential for
the effective exercise of the right to make political
choices and to participate in the elections. It was
declared that information on private funding of
political parties and independent candidates must
be recorded, preserved, and made reasonably
accessible. The Constitutional Court further said,
“there is a vital connection between a proper
exercise of the right to vote and the right of access
to information. The former is not to be exercised
blindly or without proper reflection.” The Court
cited the United Nations Convention Against
Corruption and the African Union Convention on
Preventing and Combating Corruption in support
of the need for transparency in political funding,
as a means to detect and discourage improper
influence and corruption.16 The Court went on to
cite Ngcobo CJ (as he then was) in President of the
Republic of South Africa v M & G Media Limited17
who said that, “[I]n a democratic society such
as our own, the effective exercise of the right
to vote also depends on the right of access to
information. For without access to information,
the ability of citizens to make responsible political
decisions and participate meaningfully in public life
is undermined.”18
Most African constitutions provide for access
to information as a right, inasmuch as that
information is required for public accountability or
the protection of a right. The African Charter on
Democracy, Elections, and Governance requires
state parties to ensure fair and equitable access
by contesting parties and candidates to statecontrolled media during elections.19 This can be a
standard that courts must insist on, not only during
but also between elections, to ensure that access
to information becomes a culture.
The Veritas Case (n 12).
My Vote Counts NPC v Minister of Justice and Correctional Services and Another 2018 (5) SA 380 (CC), para 35.
My Vote Counts, paras 49-51.
President of the Republic of South Africa v M & G Media Limited 2012 (2) SA 50 (CC) at para 10.
My Vote Counts NPC v Minister of Justice and Correctional Services and Another 2018 (5) SA 380 (CC) para 35.
Adopted by the Eighth Ordinary Session of the Assembly, 30 January 2007, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.
53
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents