531US1
130
Unit: $$U9
[05-01-02 10:02:37] PAGES PGT: OPIN
BUSH v. GORE
Souter, J., dissenting
due process guaranteed by the Fourteenth Amendment.
None of these issues is difficult to describe or to resolve.
I
The 3 U. S. C. § 5 issue is not serious. That provision sets
certain conditions for treating a State’s certification of Presidential electors as conclusive in the event that a dispute over
recognizing those electors must be resolved in the Congress
under 3 U. S. C. § 15. Conclusiveness requires selection
under a legal scheme in place before the election, with results determined at least six days before the date set for
casting electoral votes. But no State is required to conform
to § 5 if it cannot do that (for whatever reason); the sanction
for failing to satisfy the conditions of § 5 is simply loss of
what has been called its “safe harbor.” And even that
determination is to be made, if made anywhere, in the
Congress.
II
The second matter here goes to the State Supreme Court’s
interpretation of certain terms in the state statute governing election “contests,” Fla. Stat. Ann. § 102.168 (Supp. 2001);
there is no question here about the state court’s interpretation of the related provisions dealing with the antecedent
process of “protesting” particular vote counts, § 102.166,
which was involved in the previous case, Bush v. Palm Beach
County Canvassing Bd. The issue is whether the judgment
of the State Supreme Court has displaced the state legislature’s provisions for election contests: is the law as declared
by the court different from the provisions made by the legislature, to which the National Constitution commits responsibility for determining how each State’s Presidential electors
are chosen? See U. S. Const., Art. II, § 1, cl. 2. Bush does
not, of course, claim that any judicial act interpreting a statute of uncertain meaning is enough to displace the legislative
provision and violate Article II; statutes require interpretation, which does not without more affect the legislative char-
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents