[63]
It was also seen that the judge held that the late voting did not breach Rule 1(7) of
the Election Rules. Respondents Jonas and Simon also challenge this finding in
their counter-notices. I shall now consider the counter-appeal against the finding
of fact referred to in the foregoing paragraph first. Later in this judgment, I shall
consider the counter-appeal on the question whether the judge erred in holding
that late voting did not breach Rule 1(7).
The basic principles on appeal from fact-finding
[64]
In Golfview Development Limited v St. Kitts Development Corporation and
Another,38 this court restated the settled principles that are applicable where an
appellant seeks to impeach fact-finding by the trial judge. The basic principles are
that an appellate court will not impeach the finding of facts by a first instance or
trial court that saw and heard witnesses give evidence, except in certain very
limited circumstances. An appellate court may, however, interfere in a case in
which the reasons given by a trial judge are not satisfactory, or where it is clear
from the evidence that the trial judge misdirected himself. Where a trial judge
misdirects himself or herself and draws erroneous inferences from the facts, an
appellate court is in as good a position as the trial judge to evaluate the evidence
and determine what inference should be drawn from the proved facts. Where
therefore there is an appeal against the finding of facts, the burden upon the
appellant is a very heavy one. An appellate court will only interfere if it finds that
the court of first instance was clearly and blatantly wrong, or, as it is sometimes
more elegantly stated, exceeded the generous ambit within which reasonable
disagreement is possible. These statements of principle on appeals from the fact
finding of a trial court are often referred to as the Benmax principles, from the
locus classicus, Benmax v Austin Motors Co. Ltd.39
38
39
Saint Christopher and Nevis Civil Appeal No. 17 of 2004 (20th June 2007), at paragraphs 23 and 24.
[1955] A.C. 370; [1955] 1 All E.R. 326.
30
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents