Counsel contended that while the latter provides, in mandatory terms, that the poll
“shall commence at eight o’clock in the forenoon and shall be kept open till eight
o’clock in the afternoon of the same day and no longer”, Rule 1(7) does not do so.
Counsel buttressed his view that Rule 1(7) does not mandate the commencement
of polling at 6:00am by reference to Rule 26(1) of the Election Rules.
[84]
Rule 26(1) of the Election Rules requires the returning officer to give notice of
polling hours to the public. It states as follows:
The returning officer shall in the statement of persons nominated
include a notice of the poll stating the day on which and hours
during which the poll will be taken. [Emphasis provided by
counsel]
[85]
Mr. Mendes submitted that if Rule 1(7) mandated the commencement of polling at
6:00am, there would be no need for the returning officer to state the hours during
which the poll is to be taken. He insisted that the judge was wrong when she
rejected this submission on the ground that it would “be impossible to find that there
ever was a breach of Rule 1(7) once the polling began between 6.00am and
6:00pm, even if it started as late as 5:30pm”.51 It is to Mr. Mendes’ credit,
however, that he admitted that his suggested interpretation could, strictly
speaking, produce the result, which the trial judge feared it would.
[86]
Mr. Mendes’ response, however, was that he did not suggest an interpretation
which would mean that a decision by the returning officer to direct that polling
starts and ends at a particular time should unreasonably condense the period of
voting. This, he said, would be unlawful as such an unreasonable curtailment of
voting time would constitute an abuse of discretion and a violation of the
constitutional right to vote. This could arise, in counsel’s view, because the
probable consequence of such curtailment would be that those who want to vote
51
See paragraph 222 of the judgment.
38
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents