accordance with the election law. It simply fell for the court to examine the whole
of the evidence in order to determine whether this was so or whether the result
was affected.
She cited in authority Re Kensington North Parliamentary
Election.74 She noted75 that these basic principles were judicially acknowledged
in Edgell v Glover 76 when Newman J stated:
“The judge aptly translated the words, “it appears” into “the Court must
make up its mind on the evidence.”
The trial judge was expressly and correctly guided by these statements of
principle.
[133]
Applying the basic principles to the evidence in the St. George (Jonas) petition, the
trial judge stated77 that, in seeking to ascertain whether the election was
conducted substantially in accordance with the election law, the court must take
into consideration the period during which non-voting took place. She noted that
the hours of voting lost due to the late opening of the polls are as follows: In New
Winthorpes and Piggotts a period in excess of 2 hours, and in Potters a period in
excess of 5½. Hours. However, she stated78 that the hours of voting lost could not
in itself determine whether the election was conducted substantially in accordance
with the election law. Additionally, stated the judge, there had to be clear evidence
that as a result of the non-polling a significant percentage of the electorate was
prevented from voting in order to lead to the conclusion that there was not
substantial compliance with the election law. She cited Hackney in authority.79
[134]
The learned trial judge continued her own analysis and findings on the principles
as they relate to the evidence in the St. George petition as follows:
“[235] It follows, for example, that if there is cogent evidence before the
[1960] 1 WLR 762.
At paragraph 232 of the judgment.
76 [2003] EWHC 2566, at page 24.
77 At paragraph 233 of the judgment.
78 At paragraph 234 of the judgment.
79 (1874) 2 OM & H 77.
74
75
57
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents